Why lockdowns are the wrong policy: Swedish expert Prof. Johan Giesecke

Channel:UnHerd · Length:34:53 · Published:2020-04-17 · Views:1411261

Watch on YouTube

Summary

UnHerd interview with Swedish epidemiologist Johan Giesecke, who explains why he thinks lockdowns are the wrong policy and describes Sweden's approach during the spring 2020 pandemic.

Why HN recommends it

Commenters point to it for the Swedish insider perspective on lockdowns, with some later calling its statements prescient.

Here's an interesting interview with a senior epidemiologist partly responsible for Sweden's unconventional strategy — HN, 2020

Politics & history (other) · Medicine & infectious disease

Subtitles (excerpt)

Hello and welcome. Thanks for tuning in. You are watching Lockdown TV. This is the popup news and discussion program from Unheard. Uh throughout the lockdown weeks, we have been bringing conversations and interesting people together to work out what's going on and how we should be thinking about this current crisis. Um I'm delighted that today we are joined down the line from Sweden by um Dr. Yuan Gizeka. Um, Dr. Giseka, thank you so much for making the time today. My my pleasure. So, if I can give you you help me a little bit here, but uh you trained originally at the London School of um tropical medicine. Is that right? No. Uh it started before that actually. I used to be an infectious disease clinical doctor and worked a lot with AIDS patients during the 1980s and that's what put me into epidemiology and then I spent one year or two years at the London School of Tropical Medicine in the early 90s and then I came back to Sweden and then I became state epidemiologist for Sweden which means having control over all the infectious diseases which is the job that And now currently has. So I I actually hired him 20 years ago and then I was his boss and now he's my boss but it's working actually quite well.

On Hacker News

Here is an interview with Prof Johan Giesecke from April 2020. In hindsight one can call his statements prophetic. [VIDEO] They had a clear plan, unlike other governments like Germany, who still do not have a plan how to get out of this mess. — jansan, 2021-08
Sweden has a rather different welfare system, typical population density, income distribution, typical household demographic, urban planning and culture regarding social interactions, compared to many places that would use it as an example for what to do in this crisis. I think following the available evidence, interpreted by experts is the way to go. Ultimately the argument for Sweden's policy s… — dcanelhas, 2020-05
Unherd.com have had some of the best journalism of the crisis so far. In particular some of the interviews with epedimiologists: [VIDEO] [LINK] [LINK] — benjaminwootton, 2020-05
I'm Swedish but I live in Scotland and I've been watching the Swedish approach to COVID with great interest. I remain fairly sceptical but I also thought this interview[0] with Johan Giesecke who was the previous state epidemiologist and is advising both WHO and the current state epidemiologist interesting. In particular it seems like Sweden messed up the response in elderly care which is somethi… — K0nserv, 2020-05
Here's an interesting interview with a senior epidemiologist partly responsible for Sweden's unconventional strategy: [VIDEO] TL;DW: Preventing transmission in the long term is impossible and the actual fatality rate is likely on the order of 0.1%, so general lockdowns are pointless and being driven mostly by political considerations (something must be done and this is something). Just protect th… — 9nGQluzmnq3M, 2020-04

Related videos