GDC 2010: Sid Meier Keynote - "Everything You Know is Wrong"
Channel:GameSpot · Length:53:58 · Published:2010-03-15 · Views:100834
Summary
Sid Meier's GDC 2010 keynote on how players perceive probability in games, including how Civilization's odds were adjusted because players misjudged them.
Why HN recommends it
HN points to it as the best talk on how people misunderstand probabilities and how designers handle that.
Sid Meier (Civilization) gave a great GDC keynote in 2010 — HN, 2017
Probability & game theory · Game design
Subtitles (excerpt)
[Applause] thank you very much it's great to be here um the uh the title of this talk is uh the psychology of game design uh everything you know is wrong um I was going to call it you know um people are funny gamers are goofy uh it's all in your head or everything you know is uh questionable but I thought everything you know is wrong um kind of get the juices flowing maybe get a little more interaction um the uh the premise of this talk is that um is there any way to get the slides up in the back of the uh back of the hall um is that game play game design uh is a psychological experience gameplay is a psychological experience um when I design a game a lot of my games are based on uh historical topics uh the history of civilization railroads Pirates and the and the way I would generally approach those topics is you know make it realistic make it true make it about uh you know the more historical uh I can make the game the better it would be the more railro the game is the better the more piratey it is the better um and what I found in in taking that approach was that a lot of what I thought I knew was wrong and um the reason was because I really hadn't uh taken into account what really
On Hacker News
Sid Meier (Civilization) gave a great GDC keynote in 2010 where he describes his multi-decade struggle to convey to users ideas like "Stuff that only has a 10% chance of happening still happens sometimes." [VIDEO] Multiply that by a million daily active users and it really works out to "Stuff that has a 1-in-a-million chance of happening will happen to somebody every day". Leading to player revie… — corysama, 2017-01
I believe you're thinking of Sid Meier's GDC 2010 keynote "Everything You Know Is Wrong" [1]. The entire talk is interesting, but section on player perception of probability is about 20 minutes in. One takeaway is to be careful about how strength numbers translate into odds. If your strength is 100 and mine is 1, does that mean I have a 1% chance to out-and-out beat you? Your armored tank shouldn… — jcrites, 2019-12
This article, and some of the comments here, reminded me of another article (and GDC talk) by Civilization game designer Sid Meier, about his experience with players' perception of probability in games. Sid's talk grapples with the issue "If the game says you have 3-to-1 odds to win a battle, how often do players actually expect to win?" > When designing the combat system in Civilization: Revolut… — jcrites, 2018-07
The worst part is that even if the algorithm perfectly computed probabilities and was completely open, humans would take away incorrect information. I am reminded of this talk by Sid Meier: [VIDEO] People don't understand probabilities. They don't accept that if someone has a 75% chance of being guilty, they may very well not be. It happened again with FiveThirtyEight when everybody accused their… — espadrine, 2016-11
"Civilization Revolution" does this. Say the player loses a 75% roll, then attempts another identical 75% roll. The game will actually give you better odds for the second roll. I think it's silly -- the game basically lies to you about your odds on the second attempt. Sid Meier talked about it at length in this video: [VIDEO] . It starts around 18:25. — Fizzer, 2014-02
Related videos
- Bret Victor The Future of Programming · Joey Reid · 32:55
- The Making of: ROM City Rampage (Retro City Rampage) · VblankEntertainment · 10:45
- Farbrausch - fr-041: debris. [HD] · kb · 7:15
- How "oldschool" graphics worked Part 1 - Commodore and Nintendo · The 8-Bit Guy · 7:07
- RiftSketch: Live coding in VR with the Oculus Rift, Firefox WebVR, JavaScript and Three.js · Brian Peiris · 10:36
- Farbrausch & Neuro - Masagin (HD Stereo) · Leonard Ritter · 8:08
- 8 Bit & '8 Bitish' Graphics-Outside the Box · GDC Festival of Gaming · 1:25:34
- Juice it or lose it - a talk by Martin Jonasson & Petri Purho · grapefrukt · 15:38
- Jan Willem Nijman - Vlambeer - "The art of screenshake" at INDIGO Classes 2013 · Dutch Game Garden · 44:09
- Preventing the Collapse of Civilization / Jonathan Blow (Thekla, Inc) · DevGAMM · 1:02:41
- Why Being Delusional is a Superpower · Veritasium · 12:04
- Why Your Vote Doesn't Count · CGP Grey · 6:31
- Failing to Fail: The Spiderweb Software Way · GDC Festival of Gaming · 59:47
- Once you understand game theory, you understand the world. · Veritasium · 27:18
- Exploring the Tech and Design of Noita · GDC Festival of Gaming · 31:00
- The Voting System That Should Replace Every Election · CGP Grey · 4:27