Why CG Sucks (Except It Doesn't)

Channel:RocketJump Film School · Length:7:40 · Published:2015-08-04 · Views:11258802

Watch on YouTube

Summary

RocketJump Film School argues that we only notice bad CG while great CG is invisible, so CG seems to be everywhere ruining movies when it often is not.

Why HN recommends it

Used as a counterpoint whenever commenters claim CGI always looks fake.

This video from a few years ago is a great counterpoint — HN, 2022

Animation & visual effects · Filmmaking & video production

Subtitles (excerpt)

Transformers (2007) Director: Michael Bay VFX Supervisors: Scott Farrar, David Prescott, Richard Kidd Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace (1999) Director: George Lucas VFX Supervisors: John Knoll, Dennis Muren, Scott Squires Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (2008) Director: Steven Spielberg VFX Supervisor: Pablo Helman Rise of the Planet of the Apes (2011) Director: Rupert Wyatt VFX Supervisors: Joe Letteri, Dan Lemmon Avatar (2009) Director: James Cameron VFX Supervisors: John Bruno, Joe Letteri X-Men Origins: Wolverine (2009) Director: Gavin Hood VFX Supervisors: Eric D. Christensen, Erik Liles, Pat McClung Jurassic Park (1993) Director: Steven Spielberg VFX Supervisor: Dennis Muren The Dark Knight Rises (2012) Director: Christopher Nolan VFX Supervisor: Paul J. Franklin Mad Max: Fury Road (2015) Director: George Miller VFX Supervisors: Andrew Jackson, David Nelson, Katherine Rodtsbrooks The Mummy Returns (2001) Director: Stephen Sommers VFX Supervisors: John Andrew Berton Jr., Brad Kuehn I am Legend (2007) Director: Francis Lawrence VFX Supervisor: Janek Sirrs Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (2008) Director: Steven Spielberg VFX Supervisor: Pablo Helman

On Hacker News

This video from a few years ago is a great counterpoint: [VIDEO] It's not defending all CGI, just arguing that we only notice it when it's bad. It's basically a toupée fallacy — vlunkr, 2022-02
Related video about why people think CGI sucks or is still in the uncanny valley: [VIDEO] Basically we consider CGI bad because we only see bad CGI. If it's used properly and the director/creator understands its limitations we either don't notice it or use our suspension of disbelief and don't care. — rdoherty, 2017-10
Computer graphics are already better than a lot of people realize, because now you only "see" the bad effects. The good effects you often don't notice. Highly relevant YouTube video: [VIDEO] While they may not quite be there yet, I think a lot of the modern animated movies are deliberately affecting a style, rather than being forced into one by the technology. — jerf, 2017-06
> A good SPA is indistinguishable from a native app. Exactly. It’s like CGI in movies. People always talk about how bad CGI is, without realizing just how much good CGI they never notice. [VIDEO] — coder543, 2023-10
> CGI now somehow looks worse than VFX 10-30 years ago It's somewhat incorrect. We now have significantly more CGI, and most of it significantly better. See, e.g., Why C.G. Sucks (Except It Doesn't) [VIDEO] However, the over-reliance on CGI is a problem — illiarian, 2023-04

Related videos