The Biggest Misconception About Electricity
Channel:Veritasium · Length:14:48 · Published:2021-11-19 · Views:28290922
Summary
Veritasium argues that electric energy is carried by fields around the wires rather than by electrons moving through them, using a thought experiment with a large circuit.
Why HN recommends it
Often recommended as an eye-opening field-based explanation of electricity, though it was also controversial and criticized as pedantic.
It’s an eye opening alternative explanation — HN, 2025
Fundamental physics · Everyday physics & science demos
Subtitles (excerpt)
This video was sponsored by Caséta by Lutron. Imagine you have a giant circuit consisting of a battery, a switch, a light bulb, and two wires which are each 300,000 kilometers long. That is the distance light travels in one second. So, they would reach out half way to the moon and then come back to be connected to the light bulb, which is one meter away. Now, the question is, after I close this switch, how long would it take for the bulb to light up. Is it half a second, one second, two seconds, 1/c seconds, or none of the above. You have to make some simplifying assumptions about this circuit, like the wires have to have no resistance, otherwise this wouldn't work and the light bulb has to turn on immediately when current passes through it. But I want you to commit to an answer and put it down in the comments so you can't say, oh yeah I knew that was the answer, when I tell you the answer later on. This question actually relates to how electrical energy get from a power plant to your home. Unlike a battery, the electricity in the grid comes in the form of alternating current, or AC, which means electrons in the power lines are just wiggling back and forth. They never actually go anywhere.
On Hacker News
Only tangentially related, but I highly recommend watching Veritasium's YouTube video on electricity if you're curious as to how Maxwell's fields create the current / amp abstractions in EE [1]. It's a common misconception that electrons or current transfer energy. In reality it's the electric field that exists between the wires that is doing the heavy lifting, the electrons in the wires are just… — lchengify, 2024-01
The video in question for reference: [LINK] Interestingly, when I saw that I figured this channel for a goner because he was going to turn to the darkside, but quite contrary to expectations I feel like his channel has actually blossomed since then. His older videos are fine, but often just explaining concepts that you can find a lot of other explanations on, but some of his recent videos have ro… — jerf, 2023-09
Good intrpduction are Veritasium videos: "How Electricity Actually Works" [LINK] "The Biggest Misconception About Electricity" [VIDEO] — leonidasrup, 2026-07
The problem with (or the advantage of) the water flowing analogy, or even more broadly the discrete element model, is that it explains reality good enough to be used in most practical situations. Schematics are ubiquitous, yes they are "fake", but they are also usually "correct enough". Kind of like the incorrect Bohr's model of electrons orbiting the nucleus actually does explain the emission sp… — H8crilA, 2025-02
There's also the field theory of electricity: [VIDEO] It’s an eye opening alternative explanation to the electrons flowing like a chain theory of this article. — djsamseng, 2025-02
Related videos
- How Electricity Actually Works · Veritasium · 24:30
- Jonathan Haidt: The moral roots of liberals and conservatives · TED · 19:14
- Clickbait is Unreasonably Effective · Veritasium · 19:25
- The Unreasonable Efficiency of Black Holes · minutephysics · 6:22
- Government Surveillance: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) · LastWeekTonight · 33:14
- How Not to Land an Orbital Rocket Booster · SpaceX · 2:09
- Spherical Geometry Is Stranger Than Hyperbolic - Hyperbolica Devlog #2 · CodeParade · 4:00
- Thinking outside the 10-dimensional box · 3Blue1Brown · 25:13
- Why No One Has Measured The Speed Of Light · Veritasium · 19:05
- Why Snow and Confetti Ruin YouTube Video Quality · Tom Scott · 4:20
- The Real Story Behind Wayland and X - Daniel Stone (linux.conf.au 2013) · Mladen Mijatov · 45:35
- Fractals are typically not self-similar · 3Blue1Brown · 19:55
- Why CG Sucks (Except It Doesn't) · RocketJump Film School · 7:40
- Infinite fractions and the most irrational number · Mathologer · 13:29
- Chicken chicken chicken · Yoram Bauman · 4:06
- 15 Sorting Algorithms in 6 Minutes · Timo Bingmann · 5:50
- Lenses, Folds, and Traversals · Edward Kmett · 1:54:45
- Reverse emulating the NES to give it SUPER POWERS! · suckerpinch · 22:21
- How Star Wars was saved in the edit · RocketJump · 18:24
- I bought 1000 meters of wire to settle a physics debate · AlphaPhoenix · 22:48