Traffic Calming is Everywhere in the Netherlands

Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:5:12 · Published:2020-02-24 · Views:404323

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Not Just Bikes shows how traffic calming is built into streets across the Netherlands, from city centres to villages. Street design naturally slows cars and makes roads safer.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters point to it in road safety and pedestrian death threads as the practical alternative to US road design.

Consider this video on Dutch traffic calming — HN, 2025

Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

[bicycle bell] Traffic calming in the Netherlands is a huge topic, whole books have been written about it. Like this one: But to me, Dutch traffic calming isn't just about the techniques that are used. That's interesting, but it's almost secondary. What's really remarkable about the Netherlands is that traffic calming is everywhere. Where I've lived in Canada, and in the U.S., traffic calming is only applied if there's enough demand for it. If enough people have died at a specific location or enough people complain about it long enough, then traffic calming might be considered. For example, Toronto has this convoluted warrant system through which you need to prove that traffic calming is truly required and won't put too much of a burden on those poor drivers. Even after all this process, traffic calming in Canada is extremely minimal. Yes, this street is traffic calmed. Somebody went through that whole warrants nonsense to get this: Last summer, I was visiting the neighborhood where I grew up and saw this: The first sign says: "Traffic calmed neighborhood", the second sign says: "50 kph speed limit". Like, seriously? This two-way residential road is 10 meters wide and the quote "traffic calming" is nothing but a few speed bumps.

On Hacker News

The above comment is getting downvoted, and I suspect it's due to a misunderstanding of their intent. Yes, high speeds can make collisions (especially, as another commenter points out, to pedestrians and cyclists) more dangerous. However, just as human drivers subconsciously speed up when part of a group of cars, they are not often conscious of the environmental queues informing the speed at whic… — broguinn, 2025-05
If I'm reading it right, the advice in your comment is basically "Bad Infrastructure Planning 101" in 2023. The right way to do it is what the Dutch do: [VIDEO] It's called "traffic calming". Oh, and underground pedestrian walkways, skybridges, etc are absolutely horrible long term solutions. If you'd use one of them for extended periods of time, you'd know. They're generally under maintained ove… — oblio, 2023-03
And that still doesn't seem to stop reckless driving from killing pedestrians. The only thing that will slow drivers down is when they feel unsafe themselves, or have a risk to their vehicle. Adding signs or automatic fines doesn't do anything. You need narrower streets utilizing actual traffic calling techniques. It's such a sad sight to see signs with a "traffic calming zone" sign, but absolute… — palijer, 2022-02
I understand your situation, but please also understand that per cycled kilometer, the Netherlands is a lot safer than any other country. There exists no country with as big of a modal share with bicycles, and our accident rates involving bicycles are still super low. I'd love to get my hands on statistics on accidents per million kilometers or so, but it doesn't seem to be tracked anywhere for b… — superice, 2020-09

Related videos