How To Tell Someone They Sound Racist
Channel:Jay Smooth · Length:3:00 · Published:2008-07-21 · Views:1481249
Summary
Jay Smooth's short video on how to tell someone their words sound racist. He argues for focusing on what the person said or did rather than labeling who they are.
Why HN recommends it
HN commenters cite it in arguments about criticism, to separate attacking a comment from attacking a person.
If someone makes a racist comment, attack the comment, not the person. — HN, 2011
Subtitles (excerpt)
race the final frontier no matter what channel you watch no matter what feed you aggregate it seems like everybody everywhere is talking about race right now and when everybody everywhere is talking about race that means sooner or later you're going to have to tell somebody that they said something that sounded racist so you need to be ready and have a plan in place for how to approach the inevitable that sounded racist conversation and I'm going to tell you how to do that the most important thing that you've got to do is remember the difference between the what they did conversation and the what they are conversation those are two totally different conversations and you need to make sure that you pick the right one the what they did conversation focuses strictly on the person's words and actions and explaining why what they did and what they said was unacceptable this is also known as the that thing you said was racist conversation and that's the conversation that you want to have the what they are conversation on the other hand takes things one step further and uses what they did and what they said to draw conclusions about what kind of person they are this is also known as the I think you are a racist
On Hacker News
The point was you said it was intended to poke fun at traditional chivalry like it was a fact. But it was just your speculation. We define chivalrous differently apparently. And I never heard of someone trying to flatter a 21 year old man by wishing him a happy 60th birthday. What they said and what kind of person they are are 2 different discussions.[1] Well meaning people accept constructive cr… — pseudalopex, 2021-12
You're turning a discussion about what someone did into a discussion about who they are.[1] [1] [VIDEO] — pseudalopex, 2021-05
They didn't say or ask if he turned into a misogynist. The question is about what he said. Not what he is.[1] [1] [VIDEO] — pseudalopex, 2021-02
When telling someone that something they said was racist, it's important to keep it focused not on the person but the act. Racism and prejudice is learned, and it can certainly be unlearned. Unfortunately, you cannot unlearn mental illness. [VIDEO] — peteforde, 2018-09
The developers are not racist. My entire original point is their attitudes and intents were irrelevant. The system they created is very much racist, completely independent about how they felt in creating it; I'm not sure how you can really dispute that. The venerable Jay Smooth describes a closely-related distinction here[0]. Also, when you describe a system as racist that's somewhat different fr… — ahelwer, 2015-02
Related videos
- Music Theory and White Supremacy · Adam Neely · 44:01
- Alain de Botton: Status Anxiety · Alain de Botton · 2:23:07
- America Keeps Rejecting an ID Card It Already Has · CGP Grey · 7:15
- Seattle is Dying | A KOMO News Documentary · KOMO News · 1:00:36
- Why Are You So Angry? Part 1: A Short History of Anita Sarkeesian · Innuendo Studios · 9:35
- Incels | ContraPoints · ContraPoints · 35:04
- NVC Marshall Rosenberg - San Francisco Workshop - FULL ENGLISH SUBTITLES TRANSCRIPTION · Centrum Nadania · 3:05:57
- Immigration, World Poverty and Gumballs · NumbersUSA · 6:08
- How not to be ignorant about the world | Hans and Ola Rosling · TED · 19:09
- Millennials Don't Exist! Adam Conover at Deep Shift · Adam Conover · 24:56
- Why We Won't Raise Our Kids in Suburbia · Not Just Bikes · 12:13
- "Two incompatible sacred values in American universities" Jon Haidt, Hayek Lecture Series · Duke University Department of Political Science · 1:06:23
- Canceling | ContraPoints · ContraPoints · 1:40:27
- James Baldwin Debates William F. Buckley (1965) · The Riverbends Channel · 58:58
- Collapse of Complex Societies by Dr. Joseph Tainter · vlada888 · 1:33:25
- Why I, as a black man, attend KKK rallies. | Daryl Davis | TEDxNaperville · TEDx Talks · 18:52