For and Against National Service | Yes, Prime Minister | Comedy Greats

Channel:BBC Comedy Greats · Length:3:30 · Published:2021-09-27 · Views:664949

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A Yes, Prime Minister scene in which Sir Humphrey shows how leading questions can make a poll produce either answer on national service.

Why HN recommends it

Linked whenever surveys or polls are suspected of manipulation through question wording.

Sir Humphrey summarises it fairly well, as usual — HN, 2025

Data science & statistics · Satire & parody · Film & TV clips

Subtitles (excerpt)

What, that silly grand design? Bernard, that was precisely what you had to avoid. How did this come about? I shall need a very good explanation. - Well, he's very keen on it. - What's that got to do with it? Things don't happen just because prime ministers are very keen on them. Neville Chamberlain was very keen on peace. - You see, he thinks... He thinks it's a vote winner. - Ah. That's more serious. Sit down. What makes him think that? - Well, the party have had an opinion poll done. It seems all the voters are in favour of bringing back National Service. - Well, have another opinion poll done showing the voters are against bringing back National Service. - We can't be for it and against it. - Oh, of course they can, Bernard. Have you ever been surveyed? - Yes. Well, not me actually, my house. Oh, I see what you mean. - Bernard, you know what happens. A nice, young lady comes up to you. Obviously you want to create a good impression. You don't want to look a fool, do you? - No. - No. So she starts asking you some questions. Mr Woolley, are you worried about the number of young people without jobs? - Yes. - Are you worried about the rise in crime among teenagers? - Yes. - Do you think there's a lack of discipline in our comprehensive schools?

On Hacker News

Your solution (of tackling unemployment by tacking it onto national defense), is eerily close to what they discussed in an episode of Yes Prime Minister in the 80s. [LINK] [VIDEO] — upboundspiral, 2026-05
Social Studies practitioners' surveys, for which they use statistics, depend heavily on the wording of the questionnaire. [VIDEO] It's not a science. — SanjayMehta, 2026-03
Is it popular? I’m a parent and none of my parent friends like it. I suspect this law isn’t popular. Just the messaging of doing nothing is more unpopular. So it gets spun as this is popular. [VIDEO] — hnlmorg, 2025-10
It's all about how you ask the question; there would be a lot of people who want a thing _called_ small government, because they have been told that that is a good thing, but the _benefits_ of big government (ideally without the _costs_ of big government, but realistically most people in the US do not care about the deficit; if they did Trump would already have been deposed). Sir Humphrey summari… — rsynnott, 2025-09
I am not sure how many people were surveyed and what were the questions in these. I am reminded of this from Yes, Prime Minister [VIDEO] — dunekid, 2024-05

Related videos