harvard & aliens & crackpots: a disambiguation of Avi Loeb

Channel:Angela Collier · Length:1:06:38 · Published:2022-08-25 · Views:605143

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Physicist Angela Collier gives an hour-long critique of Avi Loeb's alien claims and reputation, placing them within the broader topic of physics crackpots. The Loeb discussion starts around the 24 minute mark.

Why HN recommends it

Frequently linked as an in-depth, well-presented skeptical take whenever Loeb's alien claims come up.

I was surprised about myself that I watched the entire thing and I guess it's because of the high quality of the presentation — HN, 2023

Cosmology & astrophysics · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

it's october 19 2017. robert work is an astronomer at a hawaiian observatory and he sees something interesting something unexpected something sharp something new and the cool thing about astronomers is that if you see something exciting every single astronomer with the capability of observing that object is going to jump to their telescope and do it like if a supernova went off in our galaxy right at this second like neutrino detectors would start like pinging a thousand people would get a text message they'd jump to their computers they'd log on and point the telescope and that's why i'm against two-factor authentication because it's just really gonna slow us down what was fascinating about this object was that though it looked like a comet or an asteroid the velocity and the eccentricity of the orbit implied that this object could not be from the solar system it was going too fast the eccentricity of the orbit was too high for the first time we saw something inside our solar system that was not from our solar system it was an interstellar object it was observed 207 times over a very short period of time and then it was gone um it's still in our solar system it's like past neptune now but we won't get to see it

On Hacker News

Yeah, that guy again. Required viewing: acollierastro harvard & aliens & crackpots: a disambiguation of Avi Loeb [VIDEO] — DemocracyFTW2, 2023-08
posted here a few days ago: [ harvard & aliens & crackpots: a disambiguation of Avi Loeb ]( [VIDEO] ) by Angela Collier. It's 1h6m long but I was surprised about myself that I watched the entire thing and I guess it's because of the high quality of the presentation and the occasional deadpan remark that keep you awake. Talk about Avi Loeb specifically start at 24 minutes. The most damning part of… — DemocracyFTW2, 2023-07
Since it's on topic, I'd like to share a small youtuber who does science communication. She covered Loeb and the topics of crackpots in science [1]. Her other video on string theory and how it damaged science communication is really good too. [1] [VIDEO] — hikingsimulator, 2023-08
Thanks to hikingsimulator's link below, here is Loeb interacting with Tarter [0]. The entire video is worth listening to and the vlogger is refreshingly fair minded. 0. [VIDEO] — adolph, 2023-08
> He's written "over 800 scientific papers". Is that... a good thing in his field? No...it really isn't. If you want a very accurate and in depth breakdown of why, i suggest you watch this: [VIDEO] If you don't want to do the whole thing, just jump to his lovely little interaction with Jill Tarter. Then look at all the comments trying to somehow give this snake oil salesman credibility. He's a pu… — Eji1700, 2023-08

Related videos