Pentagon Wars - Bradley Fighting Vehicle Evolution

Channel:66NOVA66 · Length:10:59 · Published:2011-05-10 · Views:4100959

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A roughly ten-minute scene from the movie The Pentagon Wars showing how the Bradley Fighting Vehicle's requirements ballooned through committee demands into a compromised design. It is a satirical dramatization of military procurement.

Why HN recommends it

Linked in nearly every F-35 or procurement thread as the classic illustration of feature creep and design by stakeholder committee, including in software.

It's a great example of how trying to design a product that works well for every stakeholder in every scenario leads to a Frankenstein of a product — HN, 2018

Military history & warfare · Satire & parody · Film & TV clips

On Hacker News

Reading this “We weren’t sure LCS was executing the missions it was designed for,” Commander of Naval Surface Forces Vice Adm. Roy Kitchener said in January 2022. “And so we … went out to the number of fleet commanders and said, ‘Alright, what do you want it to do? And what missions do you want it to execute based on the environment we’re in now?’” reminds me of this excerpt from a movie: Pentago… — somethoughts, 2023-04
Watch the "Pentagon Wars - Bradley Fighting Vehicle Evolution" video: [VIDEO] It's a great example of how trying to design a product that works well for every stakeholder in every scenario leads to a Frankenstein of a product that doesn't work well for anybody. This happens all too often in government (typically military) contracts. — urlgrey, 2018-03
Agreed, but more specifically here is the 10 minute video which best distills the whole movie. It's worth watching: [VIDEO] — kelvin0, 2015-06
It's a lateral move. Recall that the US is updating their nuclear stockpile[0]. This is not expanding the stockpile, but neither is it reducing it. The F-35 was created to be a one-size-fits-all solution invented by the same bureaucrats who invented Full Stack Developer or the Bradley[1] with exactly the same results. If you're talking Doomsday clock, well there is a certain country actively stat… — godelski, 2024-03
Modularity and abstraction come up against some limits when different customers have incompatible domain models, and thus different ideas of what your product ought to be. While I've seen its historical accuracy questioned, something about this satire from Pentagon Wars still resonates: [VIDEO] — Terr_, 2024-02

Related videos