Cities Without People

Channel:Jacob Geller · Length:25:08 · Published:2020-09-18 · Views:1682976

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Jacob Geller's video essay on empty cities and what they say about our relationship to places, using games, literature and aerial imagery. It touches on works such as Invisible Cities.

Why HN recommends it

HN points to Geller's essays as accessible companions to literary works and as a good summary of a story.

Jacob Geller provides a fun and effective summary within this video at 9 minutes in — HN, 2025

Transit, cities & urban planning · Gaming culture & analysis · Literature & writing craft

Subtitles (excerpt)

I’m a big fan of clouds. The tall ones, specifically. For as long as I remember, I’ve looked at those giant clouds and wondered just how big they actually were. The size of a football stadium? Of a skyscraper? Of a mountain? Try as I might, I haven’t been able to get close enough to one to break out my tape measure, but I think, this year, I might have found the next best thing- the computer-meltingly beautiful Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020. Are you seein these clouds right now? And it’s not just one type of cloud either, you can do thunder clouds or the high wispy boys, or a perfect scatter, you can decide how high or low each layer should be, you can watch how the light at different times of day and different times of year filters through them. They are, without a doubt, the best video game clouds I have ever seen. If Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020 didn’t even have a ground, and just had these infinite oceans of white to fly through, I think I’d still be satisfied. But of course, Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020 does have a ground. It has runways, for instance. So you can look at your immensely detailed cockpits, full of buttons that no one in the history of the world has known the purpose of.

On Hacker News

For those who don't have time to... "read"... this great story, Jacob Geller provides a fun and effective summary within this video at 9 minutes in [VIDEO] In his words: "It is in my opinion one of the best sci-fi stories ever written." — haiku2077, 2025-06
Video (game) essayist Jacob Geller did a few videos which mentioned this work. [LINK] [LINK] They're quite interesting, I think. The abyss really gets him going. And a few more I really like: [LINK] [LINK] [VIDEO] [LINK] — bsanr2, 2021-10
"Southern Reach Trilogy" by Jeff VanderMeer [0]. I absolutely loved every book. "Annihilation" is probably my favorite. What hooked me about the series were two things: 1) It was very, /very/ weird and 2) it often times felt like the characters had no power. "Bliss Montage" by Ling Ma [1]. The short stories felt dreamy - drifting in perspectives, places, and times. Many of the stories had a super… — cyrialize, 2023-12

Related videos