Comparing Beta & VHS on Quality: Was Beta Really Better?

Channel:Technology Connections · Length:9:51 · Published:2017-06-21 · Views:711754

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Technology Connections compares Betamax and VHS picture quality using footage from a 1979 RCA VCR and argues the Beta quality advantage was largely marketing.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as evidence that Betamax was not meaningfully better than VHS.

Technology Connections did a teardown of why Betamax wasn't better than VHS — HN, 2025

Audio & video engineering · Tech company stories & documentaries

Subtitles (excerpt)

So, you’ve found yourself looking at a side-by-side comparison of Beta and VHS in 2017. Awesome! All kidding aside, here’s a disclaimer: It’s not exactly easy to find a Beta machine in stellar shape. These recordings were made with my best Beta VCR, which is well over 30 years old now. This video has been re-uploaded to address an unfair advantage the VHS footage had in the previous version: the age of the VCR. I didn’t see this as a huge problem given it was a standard VHS unit, but user did rightly point out that the newer VHS machine has VHS HQ enabled, and it has digital signal processing which would give it an edge. So, I set up the RCA dinosaur from 1979 and recorded the output from that machine, and replaced the original VHS footage. I didn’t re-record the VHS tape with the RCA machine because it’s doesn’t record so well, so it’s possible that the VHS footage has the tiniest of edges given the tape’s been recorded on a newer machine, but still it’s being played back on a venerable antique. Note however that the audio from the original upload is still being used for the VHS segments. And with that out of the way, let’s continue. This footage comes from a simple stroll around my local area (yes this is Downtown Lombard

On Hacker News

While a worse format surely could have won something like the video wars, it doesn't seem that VHS was in fact the worse format overall: [LINK] (Part 2: [LINK] . Quality comparison: [VIDEO] ) Beta was basically optimised for one thing, reasonable cassette size, and the tradeoffs turned out probably not to be worth it. — leoc, 2026-08
This just reminds me of the people who whine about Betamax (or CCS) being better. FWIW: Technology Connections did a teardown of why Betamax wasn't better than VHS: [VIDEO] And the whole series if you actually enjoy watching these things: [LINK] — gwbas1c, 2025-11
In tests done by Technology Connections, the difference was so small as to be inconsequential. It was technically better at its slowest speed, but you could barely perceive the difference and more importantly Sony disabled the feature in the vast majority of machines sold. People wanted more than 60 minutes out of one tape. They wanted 2 hours. [VIDEO] — philistine, 2025-09
We've all collectively fallen for Sony's marketing for Betamax. It was not clearly higher quality. [VIDEO] — philistine, 2022-04

Related videos