21. Chaos and Reductionism

Channel:Stanford · Length:1:37:32 · Published:2011-02-01 · Views:1837619

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Robert Sapolsky's Stanford lecture on chaos and reductionism, which he calls one of the hardest of the course. It examines the limits of breaking systems into parts to understand them and introduces chaotic systems.

Why HN recommends it

Pointed to as a clear statement of irreducible complexity, the limits of reductionism, and why simple neuron-level explanations fall short.

acknowledging irreducible complexity irrespective of scale as he did so clearly in one of his Stanford lectures — HN, 2017

Neuroscience & the brain · Biology & biotechnology · University lectures & courses

Subtitles (excerpt)

[MUSIC PLAYING] Stanford University. And we are not going to work our way through the behavior on the right and march to the left. And instead, we'll be trying to come up with some ideas that are going to apply to everything we hear about in here. And overall, these are probably the most difficult lectures of the course, the most difficult material, in part because I'm not sure if I completely understand what I'm talking about. But also because this is intrinsically some really different ways of thinking about things in the realm of science. And that's one of the reasons why I forced you guys to read this Chaos book. And again, as I think I mentioned in the first lecture, this incites a subset of people to passionate enthusiasm about the book. It incites another small subset into just the most greatest level of irritation that this was assigned. And everybody else is just vaguely puzzled and kind of sort of sees the point, but how come? This book, when I first read it, and so my first introduction to the whole field, this was like the first book I had read where I finished it and immediately started over again, the first one since, like, Where the Wild Things Are in terms of influence.

On Hacker News

I think its a good start to learn about chaotic systems instead. For most systems, minute parameter changes can have dramatic effects on the predictability of the system [VIDEO] — animal_spirits, 2020-10
Nit: It goes a bit deeper than that. Note this talk by another Pop Sci personality Robert Sapolsky, where he talks about the limitations of western reductionism. [VIDEO] Yet his latest book on free will exclusively depended on an reductionist viewpoint. While I don't know his motivations for those changes, the fact that the paper he mentioned was so extremely unpopular that I was only one of a ha… — nyrikki, 2024-10
This is simply impossible. The premise that the brain is a big lookup table is appealing, and that sort of 1 neuron = 1 represented item concept certainly happens at the initial stages of the sensory pipeline, but if you attempt to scale it up and up to higher levels of abstraction, to the point where you have neurons that have rote memorized every orientation of your grandmothers face (and every… — IIAOPSW, 2023-03
Actually the opposite. The story of a single neuron on/off state for everything we experience is just that, a story. If you tried to build a skull large enough to hold all that, it would burst. The reality is that paradigm of hardwired neurons works well for the initial layers of processing (Eg recognizing lines and circles in visual stimuli), but that same model can't be repeated all the way up … — IIAOPSW, 2022-08
Maybe, but assuming Shermer has correctly conveyed the contents of this part of the book, Sapolsky's got a lot of nerve asserting so confidently in this book that there is such a definitively deterministic core to humans behavior at the macro level while acknowledging irreducible complexity irrespective of scale as he did so clearly in one of his Stanford lectures: [VIDEO] . I really like the guy… — lr4444lr, 2017-06

Related videos