Building a Cathedral without Science or Mathematics: The Engineering Method Explained

Channel:engineerguy · Length:11:54 · Published:2023-05-09 · Views:1061357

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Bill Hammack of engineerguy explains how medieval engineers designed stone cathedrals using rules of thumb, with no science, mathematics or literacy. He uses it to define the engineering method.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends the series as a thoughtful account of engineering as rule-of-thumb problem solving that predates formal science.

I encourage everyone to watch this series of videos. — HN, 2023

World history · Civil engineering & construction · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

This structure built some 12,000 years ago — that’s 6,000 years before Stonehenge, 5,000 years before the first pyramid — highlights that for millennia, humans have used the engineering method to solve problems long before the rise of science. In this video I define and illustrate the essence of the engineering method. This is Göbekli Tepe, an ancient ruin in southeastern Turkey. Stone structures cover nine hectares, about eighteen football fields. Filled with circular rooms, its purpose remains a mystery. Embedded in the stone walls of the rooms are decorative T-shaped pillars. Carved into the pillars are lions . . . bears . . . wild boars . . . lizards . . . spiders, and surprisingly . . . . ducks. Not only are the stones beautifully carved, they are placed with precision. To see the degree of precision look at the circular room I showed you initially. At the center are the remains of two T-pillars (the tops fell off long ago). If we look at this room from above — keep you eye on the two central pillars highlighted in red — you see two circular rooms nearby, which each have the same arrangement of pillars at their center. The pillars in the two rooms at the bottom sit on a line — with little deviation.

On Hacker News

As other comments have implied, but not explicitly said, they do their own engineering already with what they have. Since materials can be scarce and inconsistent, much of it is improvised. That in no way diminishes their efforts, results, or knowledge. If anything, that's way more impressive. Lots of engineers in the first world will throw a tantrum if they can't have things exactly their way an… — sublinear, 2026-06
What everyone is talking past here is that the Babylonians discovered what engineers call a "rule of thumb", and engineering is focused on getting things done using rules of thumb. The best possible rule of thumb is a mathematical proof or a scientific discovery, but it's by no means necessary. . Observing that something always holds and even having a formula for it is not the same thing as havin… — empath-nirvana, 2023-10
Lately I've come to understand the term engineer somewhat differently from this excellent video from the 'engineerguy': [VIDEO] He defines the Engineering Method as: 'Solving problems using rules of thumb that cause the best change in a poorly understood situation using available resources.' In that sense a Software Engineer would not necessary need to know all the complexities of the complete sy… — oscare, 2024-06
> or building slender towers supported on intricate networks of arches without engineering calculations or even Newtonian physics. In fact engineering solutions came long before Newtonian physics. Bill Hammack aka engineerguy has a good video about this: [VIDEO] — mcpackieh, 2023-09
Just yesterday I started watching the video series promoting Bill Hammack's book "The Things We Make" in which he discusses how many incredible ancient structures were built using rules of thumb rather than an actual understanding of the science /math underpinning their strength. Truly fascinating. [VIDEO] — mayormcmatt, 2023-05

Related videos