The Remote Agent Experiment: Debugging Code from 60 Million Miles Away

Channel:Google TechTalks · Length:1:10:43 · Published:2012-03-13 · Views:23133

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Ron Garret tells the story of the Remote Agent Experiment on NASA's Deep Space 1, where autonomous software controlled a spacecraft in 1999. He describes debugging Lisp code remotely from millions of miles away.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in Lisp and safety-critical software threads as the definitive firsthand account of the DS1 remote REPL debugging episode.

Ron Garret talks about DS1, a project in the 90s where a small team used Lisp — HN, 2012

Functional programming · Testing, debugging & developer tools · Space exploration & spaceflight

Subtitles (excerpt)

>> Ron Garret. >> GARRET: Thanks. Can I take a quick poll before I start? How many Lisp programmers we have in the room? Okay. So, it's fairly--a somewhat sympathetic audience. This talk grew out of a little rant that I wrote. It's originally entitled--or subtitled The Rise and Fall of Lisp with JPL. This presentation was originally given at a Lisp business group meeting, so it was very heavily slanted towards that topic. For this talk, I tried to deemphasize that little bit, make it a little less geeky, a little more general interest. And as a result, it's come out a little disjointed, not quite as coherent as it originally was. I'm going to try to sort of dynamically adjust to the interest of the audience. I wasn't quite sure exactly who was going to show up for this. And because of that, so please feel free to interrupt me with questions at any time if I blast over something that you'd like to hear more about. So, there are a couple of themes I'm going to run through this talk. Of course, autonomous control of unmanned spacecraft which was what the remote agent was about and undergirding that is some lessons learned about software development methodology and the limits of static analysis.

On Hacker News

Related Google Tech Talk: Debugging Code from 60 Million Miles Away [VIDEO] Ron Garret talks about DS1, a project in the 90s where a small team used Lisp to send an autonomous craft into space in a third of the time and at a fraction of the cost of previous comparable projects. (Yes, I couldn't have made up a more HN-friendly story if I tried.) — dmit, 2012-08
It's actually not that hard to explain, yet without experiencing it firsthand, it is hard to see what this REPL fuzz is about. So, let's take a minimal, simple example: if True: print("Hello, Python!") and the equivalent code in Clojure: (when true (println "Hello, Clojure!")) In Clojure, you can send any expression fragment like a single symbol, list or even incomplete code and it will be evalua… — iLemming, 2024-06
I'm reminded of Ron Garrett's writing/talks on remote debugging the Remote Agent for the New Millennium Deep Space 1 (DS1).[0], [1] [0]: The Remote Agent Experiment: Debugging Code from 60 Million Miles Away - [VIDEO] [1]: NASA Programmer Remembers Debugging Lisp in Deep Space - [LINK] — _emacsomancer_, 2024-04
This is what I was mainly known for: [LINK] [LINK] I think I'm most proud of this: [LINK] [LINK] though it didn't make nearly as much of a splash. I was also the tech lead on the New Millennium Deep Space One Remote Agent Executive, which sounds cool, but was really kind of a disaster. See: [VIDEO] if you want the gory details. — lisper, 2024-04
Unless you write it in CL, in which case you get a debugger REPL, and you can debug it hundred of million of km away. [VIDEO] — informatimago, 2020-04

Related videos