Bumping The Lamp

Channel:PapaG · Length:1:12 · Published:2009-09-03 · Views:423163

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A one-minute clip from Who Framed Roger Rabbit in which a swinging pendant lamp is bumped and keeps flailing, showing animators' attention to detail.

Why HN recommends it

Used as an example of going the extra mile on small details in animation and design.

This was such a small detail that it would have been forgivable if the animators had left it out entirely — HN, 2013

Animation & visual effects · Film & TV clips

Subtitles (excerpt)

ready that almost killed me boy what is this some kind of a secret room it's a root gut room hold over from prohibition oh I get it a SP e a gym Mill a hoot P tools are up here Eddie look at fire hole J this would be a great place to hide where CH your head you said you'd never take another to case what you have a change of heart nothing's changed somebody's made a py out of me and I'm going to find a five go still will you does this help yeah thanks do you mean to tell me that you could have taken your hand out of that cuff at any time no not at any time only when it was funny come on Edie where your sense of humor he always is funny or only on days when he's wondered for murder Listen My Philosophy is this if you don't have a good sense of humor you're better off dead

On Hacker News

> It's pure insanity that people ever drew, by hand, mountains of individual drawings each slightly changed and assembled them into compelling illusions to tell stories. Traditional animation by itself is nothing short of insanity, convincingly blending live action and traditional animation takes it a step further, and then there's the "Bumping the Lamp"[0] scene in Who Framed Roger Rabbit. The f… — pdpi, 2022-08
I am often pulled towards this comment for an article that asks, "Are Designers Crazy?" [0] """ No, designers aren't crazy. You just don't understand a very fundamental concept of design. It even applies to engineering. It's okay—many people have the same frustrations as you do. But those who care about the details achieve truly high quality results overall. It extends to all areas of the design,… — satvikpendem, 2021-10
This one about whether designers are crazy because the OP didn't understand why designers would care about minute details in their work. It is because attention to detail creates superlative work. It is similar to why premature optimization isn't necessarily bad for engineers. [LINK] """ No, designers aren't crazy. You just don't understand a very fundamental concept of design. It even applies to… — cercatrova, 2020-09
No, designers aren't crazy. You just don't understand a very fundamental concept of design. It even applies to engineering. It's okay—many people have the same frustrations as you do. But those who care about the details achieve truly high quality results overall. It extends to all areas of the design, not just to the parts you can't see. In the movie "Who Framed Roger Rabbit," there's a scene in… — calinet6, 2013-01

Related videos