Ian Hislop on Capital Punishment

Channel:Captain Soul · Length:2:37 · Published:2014-01-07 · Views:1014417

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A BBC Question Time clip in which Ian Hislop argues against capital punishment, rebutting the deterrence argument. He points out the problem of executing innocent people.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in threads on wrongful convictions and executions as a pithy rebuttal of the deterrence argument.

It's not a deterrent killing the wrong people! — HN, 2024

Law, policing & justice · Stand-up & sketch comedy

Subtitles (excerpt)

for 50 years private ey has pretty much in most issues exposed the miscarriage of justice and a lot of them have been murders over the years large numbers of these cases have been found to be entirely wrong um and the men convicted um almost all men the couple of women have been found innocent um so we would have killed those people and in some of those very high-profile cases which involve terrorism cases we would have made very dangerous new Martyrs by executing people who turned out not to have committed the murders involved so on a purely practical basis whatever you think it says about um the Civilized nature of your Society or not I think it would be incredibly dangerous to have capital punishment back are you are you influenced are you influenced At All by that argument of miscarriages of Justice disrespecting him but I'm not um on the basis that I think you know this this is really about our criminal justice system actually and I think if any you know for any conviction for example you need ultimate burden of proof you really do and that means that but that's his point that they that they find these mistakes all the time well I mean that's are you saying they they were guilty all

On Hacker News

I recommend watching this clip from Question Time on the subject of capital punishment: [VIDEO] I'm still shocked that we have someone as Home Secretary who thought capital punishment was a good idea. — arethuza, 2019-07
It doesn't matter how heinous the murder was if you have the wrong suspect. [VIDEO] > Priti Patel: this is about having deterrents... > Ian Hislop: It's not a deterrent killing the wrong people! — amiga386, 2024-09
This is a very good point. There seems to be no coverage of whether the actual perpetrator was ever caught. We employ and compensate the police, admins and fund the judicial system, at least partly in order to serve as a deterrent to criminals. If our system has a high percentage of false positives or punishes innocent people then that reduces the efficacy of the system as a deterrent. I'm remind… — linuxkerneldev, 2017-03
> We have the most racially diverse Cabinet ever, elected by a massive majority. Priti and Rishi enjoy huge popularity. insular = ignorant of or uninterested in cultures, ideas, or peoples outside one's own experience. I have examined Priti Patel's statements and behavior. Her moral and cultural compass would be what I would exactly define as insular. For example, going on TV justifying applying … — alfredlind, 2021-03

Related videos