violin plots should not exist

Channel:Angela Collier · Length:42:14 · Published:2023-09-15 · Views:289968

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Physicist Angela Collier rants for 42 minutes about why violin plots are a poor way to show data, citing papers on violin and bean plots. It is part lecture on how to read distributions and part opinionated critique.

Why HN recommends it

HN links it in data-visualization threads as an entertaining case against violin plots.

Here is a great rant (borderline lecture) from Angela Collier on why they aren’t [0] — HN, 2024

Data science & statistics · Data visualization & information design

Subtitles (excerpt)

did you know that you live in the Golden Age of data visualization imagine being a scientist like a hundred years ago you're typing your paper up on a typewriter with your hands on touching ink what if you make a mistake I actually I don't really know how you would fix a mistake on a typewriter I think you could pull the paper out put like the white out on it and then you would have to realign it perfectly and then move the little ticker across and you could do that after it's dried but that seems just like a huge mess but how would you put in a plot you would draw it with your hands you would take rulers and protractors and stencils for the lettering and you would draw the plot and then you would mail it to a journal who would then make a stencil or like an etching of it and put it in wow can you imagine how little plots were in papers back then because who's gonna make a plot they can read the table they can make their own plot just give them instructions on how to make the plot [Music] foreign and you have photocopiers in like the 50s and 60s and you could draw a plot and you can make copies of it a lot more easily and you could do really cool things with Graphics that way and make pretty nice plots jump forward even further you have

On Hacker News

I disagree about violin plots being better. Here is a great rant (borderline lecture) from Angela Collier on why they aren’t [0] [0] [VIDEO] — j_bum, 2024-06
I have never liked violin plots,but I am very much not in the field of data visualisation. Just a week ago I stumbled on a video titled "violin plots should not exist" which made things fall into place: [VIDEO] — bjoli, 2023-11
I see violin plots on the front page. Just say no to violin plots. In almost any situation you either want to talk about the actual distribution (in which case plotting the distribution on one side of the line arranged horizontally is significantly superior to plotting it vertically on both sides of the line for some reason as a violin plot does) or you want to talk about the quartiles etc in whi… — seanhunter, 2026-06
> There are other distribution chart types that can be useful in specific situations, such as frequency polygons, violin plots, cumulative distribution plots, and bee swarm plots, but the three types that I described above are the easiest ones to grasp, and are able to communicate most of the insights that are needed for day-to-day decision-making in most organizations. (I’m not mentioning histog… — karmakaze, 2024-06

Related videos