Railroad tank car vacuum implosion

Channel:Tom Brattain · Length:0:18 · Published:2008-09-29 · Views:6738758

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A brief demonstration of a railroad tank car imploding after a vacuum is pulled with its safety valves disabled.

Why HN recommends it

HN people link it as a striking illustration of atmospheric pressure crushing vessels, in threads on vacuum airships, hyperloop and the Titan sub.

it effectively demonstrates how violent and quick an implosion would be — HN, 2023

Everyday physics & science demos · Mechanical & precision engineering

On Hacker News

> a buckling mode, which is inherently unstable. As soon as it goes, it goes all at once. Example of implosion of a railroad tank car: [VIDEO] — pfdietz, 2023-06
This is likely less the case when the pressure differential is ~480 bar. Failure is going to occur on the order of fractions of a second at those huge pressures. (Fortunately?) Here's a pressure vessel failing at only 1 bar: [VIDEO] — Ruthalas, 2023-06
There's obvious differences between the Oceangate sub and this (1 atm difference, this is a thinner steel(?) railroad tanker not a sub), but I think it effectively demonstrates how violent and quick an implosion would be: [VIDEO] Video contents: An experiment where the vacuum safety valves were removed from an oil tanker railroad car, and a vacuum was placed inside the car, resulting in it crumpl… — andrewmunsell, 2023-06
The point is the extreme, rapid force involved. Imploding or exploding, nine atmospheres is gonna suck. 400 atmospheres is... like standing under a nuclear bomb. The good news is it doesn't hurt, at all. Someone else on the thread posted a video of a one atmosphere implosion ( [VIDEO] ). 400x the pressure here. — ceejayoz, 2023-06
I can't believe nobody has shown how violent vacuum implosions can be. Here are some of my favorite vacuum implosions: Train car imploding: [VIDEO] Vacuum chamber imploding: [LINK] — pontifier, 2023-02

Related videos