Have the Boomers Pinched Their Children’s Futures? - with Lord David Willetts

Channel:The Royal Institution · Length:47:25 · Published:2020-01-23 · Views:1047621

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Lord David Willetts argues at the Royal Institution that the post-war baby boomers gained wealth and security at the expense of younger generations. He draws on his book The Pinch, covering housing, wealth and social policy in the UK.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters point to it as a clear exposition of intergenerational unfairness in housing and wages, especially from a UK angle.

One of the best expositions of the problem I've seen is this talk — HN, 2021

Labor, work & inequality · Social issues & culture

Subtitles (excerpt)

if you had a choice between being born in a very large cohort with many other people the same age as you or a small cohort not many people in your age group compared with the generations older and younger than you which would you choose the conventional answer the common sense really is choose to be in a small cohort travel through life business class not economy class fewer competitors in the jobs market fewer competitors in the housing market so life should be easier the argument and that was the argument of classic demographers from Malthus through to Richard Easterlin the argument in my book the pinch is that if you look at modern Britain the opposite is the case being born in a big generation is better than being born in a small one and the big generation I'm particularly thinking of the Boomers and I see perhaps one or two examples here in the Royal Institution this evening and this chart defines who the boomers are and shows just how big a generation we are because this is the instead of all the elaborate sort of fertility rates this is just a very crude chart of how many babies have been born in the United Kingdom over roughly the last century and you can see and I think this chart is one of the most

On Hacker News

There is definitely a serious intergenerational fairness issue here. One of the best expositions of the problem I've seen is this talk by Tory peer (and boomer!) Lord David Willetts. [VIDEO] — nickcox, 2021-06
You might find this video interesting from a UK perspective, I suspect with a mix of overlap and difference to the USA: [VIDEO] David Willets draws comparison of "boomers" to other generations, and includes what is paid into healthcare vs. what is consumed in a lifetime. — zbuf, 2022-08
I think a good explanation of the phenomenon is detailed here: [VIDEO] (it's a 50 min talk and targets the UK, but it's applicable to the Western world IMHO). The summary is: - People are working more and reaping less and less from their labor - Social security is getting both worse and less accessible for people in the working age - Working people in general have a much harder time entering the … — marcyb5st, 2022-07
You are looking at specific instances. For me it's about the systemic, large scale effects of the system. People routinely partake in exploitative systems without ill intent. The examples you provide could be applied in spirit to child labour. Is every instance of child labour immoral? I don't think so. But using the example of, how you as a 15 year old mowed some lawns to defend systemic child e… — Voultapher, 2024-05
Older people being richer is actually a relatively modern phenomenon. Ref: "Have the Boomers Pinched Their Chiren's Futures", David Willets, Royal Society lecture. [VIDEO] — TRiG_Ireland, 2023-05

Related videos