Leaping the chasm from proprietary to open: A survivor's guide

Channel:Bryan Cantrill · Length:43:28 · Published:2015-08-18 · Views:14526

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Bryan Cantrill's OSCON 2015 talk on moving a proprietary product to open source, drawing on Sun's history with Solaris and illumos, licensing choices and the relicensing after Oracle's acquisition.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters cite it for the history of open source at Sun and Oracle, and for Cantrill's explanation of licensing choices.

As usual Bryan Cantrill is just brilliant at explaining stuff. — HN, 2020

Software practice, open source & careers · Operating systems & kernels · Linux & open-source ecosystems

Subtitles (excerpt)

um I'm Brian canell um I'm the CTO of joint I feel the expectations have been set very very high you're expecting me to have kind of a seizure on stage I don't know if I'm going to be able to oblig or not um I am going to talk about leaving the chasm from proprietary to open um I feel that I should kind of come in uh in bandages I've leapt this Chasm so many times and I've been injured so many times and I've kind of sworn to never leap it again um the it's the last one was kind of the last one for me but we're going to go through all of this um but first we're going as I am want to do um whe let's turn back the history dial and let's look at the history of Open Source because in the beginning in the beginning of the beginning it was actually all source code um there was no such thing as open source because there were really no such thing as proprietary binaries because you just shipped the software and by the way the software wasn't the valuable thing it was the the iron was the valuable thing the metal was the valuable thing the software was just something that a a bunch of hippies wrote I mean it wasn't actually that interesting um over time it became clear that actually the software had the value that actually

On Hacker News

There's a very interesting talk on the matter by Bryan Cantrill where he explained that the gpl was unsuitable for their scope for a number of valid reasons, including the fact that the gpl vitality would have affected indipendent hardware vendors too, iirc. And some more cases. I hope I didn't write bs, however here is the talk of you want to know more and with more details: [VIDEO] (leaping the… — znpy, 2020-08
MPL 2.0 has been the preferred license for CTO Bryan Cantrill and crew for more than a decade: “And because any conversation about open source has to address licensing at some point or another, let’s get that out of the way: we opted for the Mozilla Public License 2.0. While relatively new, there is a lot to like about this license: its file-based copyleft allows it to be proprietary-friendly whi… — lloydde, 2024-01
Unsurprisingly -- and as happens almost reflexively on any HN post involving Oracle -- my talk from LISA 2011[0] has already been cited here. I expanded on that in my OSCON 2015 talk[1], to which I would add this: thinking about Oracle as "evil" is really the wrong way of thinking about them; to think of them as diabolical is to infuse the place with a kind of humanity (if crooked) that it doesn'… — bcantrill, 2023-10
They definitely changed one of the licenses, and in fact in the most brazen way possible -- they relicensed OpenSolaris to proprietary![0][1] Your point stands, though: illumos very much outpaced and outlived it.[2] [0] [LINK] [1] [VIDEO] [2] [LINK] — bcantrill, 2023-08
So, that rant actually predates Oracle v. Google. (For a bit of a history of my LISA talk that you quoted, and then my added color on Oracle v. Google see [0].) Oracle has shown everyone over and over again who they are; it shows how deep the mistrust in Red Hat has become that Oracle seems benign by comparison. [0] [VIDEO] — bcantrill, 2023-07

Related videos