Hydrogen Will Not Save Us. Here's Why.

Channel:Sabine Hossenfelder · Length:20:01 · Published:2023-01-14 · Views:2404676

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Sabine Hossenfelder explains why hydrogen is a poor answer for decarbonization, covering how most hydrogen comes from fossil fuels, the efficiency losses of green hydrogen and reliance on rare metals in fuel cells.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it in hydrogen strategy threads as a concise skeptical summary of why hydrogen is not yet viable.

Her point is that it is not a good choice for decarbonization — HN, 2023

Climate policy, solutions & debate · Renewables, batteries & storage

Subtitles (excerpt)

Today I want to talk about something light. Hydrogen. Hydrogen is one of the currently most popular alternatives to fossil fuel in transport. Many companies and nations have put money into it. In 2021, the number of hydrogen-fueled passenger cars bought in the UK was 12. Does that sound like a booming business? Not exactly. Indeed, a report from the British Science and Technology Committee that just appeared last month warned that “we do not believe that [hydrogen] will be the panacea to our problems that might sometimes be inferred from the hopes placed on it”. Ouch. So what’s the deal with hydrogen? Hope or hype? That’s what we’ll talk about today. Hydrogen is the first element of the periodic table. If you mix it with oxygen and put fire to the mixture you get water. This reaction releases energy, so if you do it under controlled conditions, you can drive a motor or turbine with it. The only exhaust you get is pure water, no carbon dioxide, no nitrogen oxides, no particulates, no radioactive waste, no chopped-up birds. It’s really difficult to complain about pure water. But let’s not give up that easily, certainly we can find something to complain about. For example, hydrogen is a gas that, at normal atmospheric pressure and temperature,

On Hacker News

If you have some time: [VIDEO] (Sabine Hossenfelder) If I remember video correctly, summary would be: not yet — funnymony, 2023-06
Sabine Hossenfelder recently made a video about hydrogen. Her point is that it is not a good choice for decarbonization, but as part of the video she goes though the various "hydrogen colors" and their meaning. [VIDEO] — nazgul17, 2023-01
Hydrogen, at the moment at least, is anything but green. In 2019 95% of the hydrogen produced globally was coming from fossil fuels (black, gray and brown hydrogen). [VIDEO] — otikik, 2023-03

Related videos