27c3 - Desktop on the Linux... (and BSD, of course) - Wolfgang Draxinger (+ Lennart Poettering)
Channel:SirPumpkin · Length:55:44 · Published:2011-01-01 · Views:38858
Summary
A 27c3 talk on the Linux desktop (GNOME) by Wolfgang Draxinger, repeatedly interrupted and corrected by Lennart Poettering from the audience. The description notes much of the talk's content is disputed.
Why HN recommends it
HN points to it as a vivid example of the clash between two philosophies of Linux desktop design, often in systemd and Wayland arguments, though many find it disrespectful.
well worth to watch to see the two different approaches to clash. — HN, 2020
Operating systems & kernels · Linux & open-source ecosystems
Subtitles (excerpt)
for letting me come on come on let's go thank you so good evening uh I'm wolfinger I known as D wolf in the Munich CCC Alpha and today I want to give a talk which rose some I don't want to say controversy it when it was announced on the uh 273 C3 far plan uh it spun a few very let's say pissed off block reaction or people never saw the slides they just saw my abstract so what is this talk about it's called desktop on the Linux uh for a long time it's has only always been set when will Linux arrive on the desktop on the average workers's computer well I think this time is long here there are Linux installations in many organizations Munich the city network is now running on Linux in a large number of clients uh big universities have Linux exclusive uh networks now when I say Linux I of course also mean BSD but BSD is not as widespread on the desktop it's more a server thing and there's also Solaris uh BSD and Solaris keep their distributions very centralized so there's only fre BSD distribution only couple of Solaris distributions this is different to Linux where there's a wild bunch of things out there first two disclaimers this talk is highly opinionated uh this comes from my experiences working as a systems administrator it is biased for being someone
On Hacker News
This was an entertaining talk from CCC in 2011 on desktop Linux. 'datenwolf' was the speaker, and he starts talking about sound in Linux here. [1] He's quickly interrupted by the maintainer of PulseAudio, and this interruption continues throughout the talk. My takeaway was that if there was still this amount of confusion and misunderstanding in the community, my frustrating experiences with sound… — justsee, 2013-05
If you think that the OpenBSD has it right, why don't you use it as a desktop, too? Why aren't you running a virtual machine of Windows 7 under OpenBSD? Probably because there's no proper virtualization support in OpenBSD. Linux is complex because sometimes it has too be, not just for the sake of it. systemd (which is great in my opinion) wouldn't be possible without cgroups. Should I also mentio… — ciupicri, 2013-03
There is no split "terrible for users, great for some developers". Casual users do have issue with X; see this thread recently on HN: [LINK] . Would you consider that normal for users to handle? Of course not. Casual users having no issue with X is a lie. The fact is, that some subsytems on Linux are pile of hacks piled upon something built on assumptions that are no longer true. X11 is one of su… — vetinari, 2021-02
It's not that simple; explaining one reason why something would not work means re-examing many of the underlying assumptions and not many like to go deeper than that one problem at hand in isolation. The "ok, how would you do it" forces thinking about underlying issues, because the solution you propose has to account for factors you otherwise wouldn't think of. It is not a new problem either; thi… — vetinari, 2020-08
Do any of the videos involve prominent systemd contributors interrupting the presenters, like in the notorious "Desktop on the Linux" video at [VIDEO] ? — federererer, 2015-11
Related videos
- Roger Penrose: Physics of Consciousness and the Infinite Universe | Lex Fridman Podcast #85 · Lex Fridman · 1:27:57
- The Tragedy of systemd · linux.conf.au · 47:18
- The Thirty Million Line Problem · Molly Rocket · 1:48:55
- VCF East: Ken Thompson interviewed by Brian Kernighan · Vintage Computer Federation · 1:03:51
- The Real Story Behind Wayland and X - Daniel Stone (linux.conf.au 2013) · Mladen Mijatov · 45:35
- LISA11 - Fork Yeah! The Rise and Development of illumos · USENIX · 1:04:03
- Tech Talk: Linus Torvalds on git · Google · 1:10:15
- USENIX ATC '21/OSDI '21 Joint Keynote Address-It's Time for Operating Systems to Rediscover Hardware · USENIX · 1:06:19
- AT&T Archives: The UNIX Operating System · AT&T Tech Channel · 27:27
- DebConf 14: QA with Linus Torvalds · Adnan Hodzic · 1:11:43
- Unix and Google · FOAM · 7:15
- Gtk to Qt - a strange journey [linux.conf.au 2014] · Konstantin Bläsi · 46:05
- Bryan Cantrill on Jails and Solaris Zones · PapersWeLove · 1:45:46
- Containers From Scratch • Liz Rice • GOTO 2018 · GOTO Conferences · 42:53
- User-level threads....... with threads. - Paul Turner - Google · Linux Plumbers Conference · 33:59
- Using a 1930 Teletype as a Linux Terminal · CuriousMarc · 16:33