Comparing Tesla, Ford, & VW's Electrical Architectures

Channel:Munro Live · Length:41:43 · Published:2021-05-07 · Views:380712

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Sandy Munro sits down with engineers from 3IS to compare the electrical architectures of the Tesla Model Y, Ford Mach-E and VW ID.4. They discuss ECU counts, bus architectures and what the differences mean for cost and integration.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as a fair, technical comparison and cites it when discussing why legacy automakers have more boxes and complexity than Tesla.

I'm not a Tesla fanboy but I didn't think it was biased. — HN, 2021

Repair, teardowns & right to repair · Cars, EVs & motorcycles

Subtitles (excerpt)

hey boys and girls um today we've got a special treat uh we've got um 3is with us and what we're going to do is we're going to do a little bit of a comparison to talk about vehicle electric and electronic architecture so today what we're going to be looking at is the model y the maki and the in the vw id4 and you've probably heard enough about me so what i'm gonna do is i'm gonna i'm gonna ask everybody to kind of give a quick introduction on themselves their background a little bit so i'm gonna start with dave and then dave will and then we'll we'll go around the table here so dave you wanna so hello i'm uh dave warner i'm one of the senior electrical uh engineers with sandy's team been with him for about 15 years and uh glad to be here for this discussion great hey guys i'm sam balestri um director of architecture and systems at 3is i've got about 30 over 35 years of experience in developing electrical systems components and architectures primarily at the oem level good day dale cook here um also with 3is and director of electrical electronics um i got a few more years and sam will just say 40 years or so of automotive electronics experience mostly at uh at what was known as chrysler

On Hacker News

I'm not a Tesla fanboy but I didn't think it was biased. E.g.: Right off the bat he talks about the number of ECU[1] of Tesla compared to others. He points out that this will result in inferior quality due to the number of connections. A no-brainer with cascading effects which has many other advantages for Tesla[2]. Spelling this out will upset a lot of people because it's a valid attack that als… — DyslexicAtheist, 2021-05
* >and was quite a bit cheaper* There are reasons why your ID.4 is cheaper than the others (and it always boils down to quality of the parts). Take a look at this Tesla, Ford, & VW's Electrical Architectures for instance. There are other tear-downs that can confirm [VIDEO] — gotmedium, 2021-10
I think it's the same with everything like agile software development etc. There are some ideas with some good parts, but the way people end up applying them can cause a lot of problems. People should understand the domain, do risk analysis, change management etc. For example car companies are suffering from chip shortages. Maybe they should have stockpiled more? But on the other hand, the "parts… — Gravityloss, 2021-09

Related videos