Numberphile v. Math: the truth about 1+2+3+...=-1/12

Channel:Mathologer · Length:41:44 · Published:2018-01-13 · Views:3269316

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Mathologer examines the infamous Numberphile claim that 1+2+3+... equals -1/12, explaining what is wrong with the calculation and how it connects to real math like the zeta function and analytic continuation.

Why HN recommends it

HN points to it as the in-depth rebuttal to the Numberphile video that explains why the 'proof' is wrong yet the result is meaningful.

Mathologer did a fairly in-depth video[1] into why this proof is wrong — HN, 2020

Pure mathematics · Recreational & visual math

Subtitles (excerpt)

Welcome to the first Mathologer video of the year. Today it's about something very serious and so I'm wearing a totally black t-shirt. You all like Numberphile right? Me too, except for this one video over there in which they prove the infamous identity 1+2+3+...=-1/12 using some simple algebra that even kids in primary school should be able to follow. Since this video was published in 2014 over six million people have watched it and more than 65,000 have liked it. Unfortunately, pretty much every single statement made in this video is wrong. And by wrong I mean wrong in capital letters. In particular, as anybody who knows any mathematics will confirm 1+2+3+... sums to exactly what common sense suggests it should namely plus infinity. And this video was not published on the 1st of April. Also, as we all know, the Numberphile videos are presented by smart guys, in this case university physics professors, who do know their maths and who are definitely not out to mislead us. So how did they get it so horribly wrong and what did they really want to say. Well, they started out with some genuinely deep an amazing connection between 1 + 2 + 3 etc and the number -1/12 but in the effort to explain this connection in really, really

On Hacker News

I know you're asking about Computerphile, but this video explains how one of the Numberphile videos is wrong: [VIDEO] — jonnytran, 2022-07
I find a response video to it more enlightening. It's often found as the number one related video. [VIDEO] — crvdgc, 2021-10
That proof (and the more general statement) is not correct because it makes assumptions about infinite summation of divergent series that are not true. There is a link between the sum of natural numbers -- namely, the analytic continuation of the Reimann Zeta function has Z(-1) = -1/12. But the Zeta function is only defined to equal the sum of inverse powers for Re(z) > 1. And under a specific de… — cyphar, 2020-11
Burkard Polster's (Mathologer) videos on the subject are probably going to be more useful than Numberphile. Numberphile merely presents a trick; Mathologer points out both that it's patent nonsense [0] and that it's useful patent nonsense [1]. [0] [VIDEO] [1] [LINK] — stan_rogers, 2020-02
Just spent 5 minutes making a script to find all the links in this thread and then 'score' them on the number of votes. Here's all the channels with 2 or more: 6 Votes: [LINK] [LINK] 5 Votes: [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] 4 Votes: [LINK] 3 Votes: [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] 2 Votes: [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK… — djaychela, 2022-07

Related videos