TMS Bicycle, stable without gyros or trail (TMS=two-mass-skate)
Channel:Arend Schwab · Length:2:39 · Published:2011-04-15 · Views:44502
Summary
Arend Schwab demonstrates a research bicycle, the two-mass-skate design, that balances itself without gyroscopic effects or trail. It challenges the common explanations for why a moving bicycle stays upright.
Why HN recommends it
HN commenters cite it as the author's own demonstration of research showing that bicycle stability is not explained by gyroscopes.
Explanation of the research in question behind this article, as well as a demonstration of the bike they based the research on. — HN, 2013
Fundamental physics · Everyday physics & science demos · Mechanical & precision engineering
Subtitles (excerpt)
Long known but still amazing is that a moving bicycle can balance itself. Most people think that balance follows from a gyroscopic effect of the spinning wheels. Well, around 1910 that's what Felix Klein of the Klein bottle, Arnold Sommerfeld nominated 81 times for the Nobel Prize and Fritz Noether, the brother of Emmy Noether thought. On the other hand, a famous paper from the 1970s by David Jones, published twice in Physics Today, claims bicycle stability is also because of something called trail. Where trail is the distance the front wheel trails behind the steer axis. Just like in a shopping cart where the contact is behind the support axis. Jones identified trail in the bicycle front wheel assembly and insisted that this trail was a necessary part of bicycle stability. We suspected that such simple images are missing at least part of the picture. To find the essence of bicycle self-balance, we looked at simpler and simpler dynamical models until we found a minimal two-mass skate bicycle that theory told us should be self-stable. This bicycle has no gyroscopic effect due to counter-rotating wheels and no trail. Moreover, we built such a bicycle based on the theory to prove the point.
On Hacker News
We do know, here is the paper that the journalist refers to: [LINK] And here is a great video by the author: [VIDEO] Short answer: "a bicycle should turn into a fall." — schoper, 2013-08
[1] Explanation of the research in question behind this article, as well as a demonstration of the bike they based the research on. They very clearly describe (at the end of the video) that even with gyroscopic and tracking forces removed, the two most important factors are where the center of gravity is, and the tendency to turn into a fall (arguably just the second, but it is caused by the loca… — aray, 2013-08
There was still active research into why bicycles are stable as recently as 2011. Here's a talk about that research: [VIDEO] If the bicycle was some sort of "obvious" machine, people wouldn't still be studying the basic stability mechanics 200 years later. Very few things are as simple as they seem. Even levers can get a bit complicated. — nitwit005, 2019-07
I don't think either of us understands that experiment. Fortunately, actual engineers have proven that bicycles don't stay upright from gyroscopic effects. [0] [1] If you want to experiment, try riding a bike that can't be turned. You might want to wear a helmet for that one. [0] [LINK] [1] [VIDEO] — jessaustin, 2015-09
Related videos
- Google I/O 2012 - Go Concurrency Patterns · Google for Developers · 51:27
- AT&T Archives: Similiarities of Wave Behavior (Bonus Edition) · AT&T Tech Channel · 28:02
- Around The Corner - How Differential Steering Works (1937) · US Auto Industry · 9:30
- Heat Pumps: the Future of Home Heating · Technology Connections · 35:15
- Detergent packs are kinda wishy-washy (Dishwashers Explained) · Technology Connections · 32:34
- Mechanical Computer (All Parts) - Basic Mechanisms In Fire Control Computers · Excelsior10000 · 41:53
- The Antique Toaster that's Better than Yours · Technology Connections · 18:28
- U.S. NAVY BASIC MECHANISMS OF FIRE CONTROL COMPUTERS MECHANICAL COMPUTER INSTRUCTIONAL FILM 27794 · PeriscopeFilm · 19:42
- The Ingenious Design of the Aluminum Beverage Can · engineerguy · 11:39
- Richard Feynman Fire · nebulajr · 4:43
- Origins of Precision · Machine Thinking · 30:32
- I bought 1000 meters of wire to settle a physics debate · AlphaPhoenix · 22:48
- Building a realistic artificial sun (for dark winter days) · DIY Perks · 19:44
- Elevator Hacking: From the Pit to the Penthouse · DeviantOllam · 1:55:53
- The Speed of Light is NOT About Light · PBS Space Time · 12:46
- Brown; color is weird · Technology Connections · 21:14