Feynman: 'Greek' versus 'Babylonian' mathematics

Channel:TehPhysicalist · Length:10:20 · Published:2012-05-17 · Views:376870

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A clip of Richard Feynman contrasting the Greek and Babylonian traditions of mathematical reasoning. It compares the axiomatic approach of mathematicians with how physicists use mathematics.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it when discussing how math should be learned and taught, and why physics isn't built from axioms.

Feynman was an excellent communicator — HN, 2015

Pure mathematics · Fundamental physics · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

of mathematics mathematics then is a way of going going from one set of statements to another it's evidently useful in physics because we have all these different uh ways that we can speak of things and it permits us to develop consequences and analyze the situations and rechange the laws in different ways and to connect all the various statements so that as a matter of fact the total amount that a physicist knows is very little he has only to remember the rules for getting from one place to another and he's able to do that do it then in other words all of the various statements about equal times of forces in a direction of the radius and so on are all interconnected by reasoning now an interesting question comes up is there some pattern to it is there a place to begin fundamental principles and deduce the whole works or is there some particular pattern or order in nature in which we can understand that these are more fundamental statements and these are more consequential statements there are two kinds of ways of looking at mathematics which for the purpose of this lecture I will call the Babylonian tradition and the Greek tradition in Babylonian schools in mathematics the student would learn something by

On Hacker News

> What is simple and clear about Python? .. it's really a pretty complex language with a deep ecosystem Here's a helpful video from Feynman that kinda explains it: [VIDEO] Python language (ditto Perl, Ruby..) uses Babylonian approach, while the languages with more fundamental building blocks (like say Scheme, Haskell..) are more like Greek approach. So Python it is not simpler as a language per s… — asgard1024, 2015-09
Here's the part of the lecture mentioned in the article: [VIDEO] Feynman was an excellent communicator, it's rare that having an intermediary "explain" what he was saying adds more than it takes away. — nerd_stuff, 2015-09
By linear I did not mean the order in which you study, but rather how your understanding builds up, as in, how much time you put in, and how much you grow. For example if your native language is subject verb object (cows eat grass) it is quite linear to learn subject object verb (cows grass eat) languages (e.g. Japanese), you put in time, and you make progress. There are other subjects where when… — throwaway71271, 2023-08
There is no such thing as "bottoms up" in mathematics, I think a relatively broad examination of mathematics might be useful so that you can discover what is relevant to the subjects you are actually interested in. I learned this the hard way. Here you have Feynman talking on this: [VIDEO] Finding a real world use case for the math you learn will be crucial if you self-study to keep yourself moti… — bryanph_, 2018-03
> causality is still a strong axiom The "causality axiom" is a nice (or trivial) statement in philosophy. But as far as we know, there's no such axiom in any mathematical theory proved to match physical reality, and nothing so clear cut in modern theoretical physics at all afaik... Also, physics isn't that much built on axioms, in general: [VIDEO] (Summarizing Feynman: you still get from time to … — nnq, 2015-09

Related videos