RailsConf 09: Robert Martin, "What Killed Smalltalk Could K
Channel:O'Reilly · Length:1:00:55 · Published:2009-05-08 · Views:86774
Summary
Robert Martin's RailsConf 2009 talk looks at why Smalltalk lost out despite its technical strengths. He draws lessons about language communities and arrogance that he argues could hurt Ruby too.
Why HN recommends it
HN cites it in discussions of language evangelism, community dynamics and zealotry, as an accessible account of how a good language can die for non-technical reasons.
I find this talk [0] very informative and useful while interacting with other languages and communities. — HN, 2022
Programming language design · Python, Ruby & scripting languages · Software practice, open source & careers
Subtitles (excerpt)
[Music] [Applause] we're very excited to Welcome to the stage Bob Martin of object [Applause] Mentor bright lights so the title of my talk today oh wait before I do that ASAC are you here M up here that timer can start now it says one hour all you can keep it at one hour for as long as you want you want to speak as well no you don't need to speak I don't think anyone wants to hear from you would you spread your hands out like this no you yeah no no no no yeah good good okay all right so fine yeah rotate like so good hands out at Jesus style good all right so imagine that the width of aac's arms are the life span of the earth uh roughly 5 billion years from here to here this is where we are right there and here is the solar nebula just about to contract now somewhere right around here there was a supernova about billion years ago some star in our general neighborhood decided to blow its guts up all over the sky and the shock wave of that event smashed into a cloud of neutral hydrogen right about here and caused it to start to collapse we actually have grains of the material from that original Supernova or at least we think they are embedded into comets and things like that you'll have to hold your hands up nice good okay so right here is
On Hacker News
> your arguments against Rust come off as biased. Yes, I'm pretty aware of this, and I keep this bias voluntarily, because Rust is generally touted (hyped?) as a Silver Bullet, and I'm wary of Silver Bullets. So, I want to highlight that fact. > Sorry if I came across as rude. No hard feelings. As I said, I'm not under delusion of a perfect life. I just said it. > I just find it slightly puzzling… — bayindirh, 2024-03
We always make this discussion with friends. I don't think every language should tick the boxes the same way. I also personally like Go a lot. It's filling the gap between C++ and Python for me. If I need something compiled with proper threading support, but C++ would be an overkill, I reach for Go. Go is designed with a human centric view, IMHO: "Make writing great programs easier rather than de… — bayindirh, 2022-09
Quite interesting, maybe one should also check this older talk: Robert Martin, "What Killed Smalltalk Could Kill Ruby", 2009 [VIDEO] — pjmlp, 2016-11
After watching a few Alan Kay talks where he pines for Smalltalk, I happened to watch this Robert Martin talk "What killed Smalltalk could kill Ruby". [VIDEO] The tldw reasons he gives for why Smalltalk died: - too easy to make a mess where adding complexity would be punished late. - arrogance - community isolated itself from the world and did not address common industry needs - commercial only -… — duncanawoods, 2015-08
For some context on Martin's comments his talk on how arrogance effected Smalltalk is probably relevant: [VIDEO] and probably worth watching if you enjoy Uncle Bob's soulful stylings and are interested in his thoughts about programming language communities. — brudgers, 2015-07
Related videos
- Harwell Dekatron / WITCH Reboot tnmoc.org · TNMoC · 0:49
- BlueHat IL 2019 - Andrew "bunnie" Huang - Supply Chain Security: "If I were a Nation State...” · Microsoft Israel R&D Center · 45:37
- The Fall of The Simpsons: How it Happened · Super Eyepatch Wolf · 31:08
- LEADERSHIP LAB: The Craft of Writing Effectively · UChicago Social Sciences · 1:21:51
- Debt: The First 5,000 Years | David Graeber | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:21:10
- The Computer Programme (1): It's Happening Now (Introduction to Computing) · Jesús Zafra (Lobogris) · 25:23
- Literate Devops with Emacs · Howard Abrams · 28:36
- MIX08 Microsoft Office 2007: The Story of the Ribbon (1 of 10) · creativecrewchannel · 10:00
- CppCon 2017: Carl Cook “When a Microsecond Is an Eternity: High Performance Trading Systems in C++” · CppCon · 1:00:07
- CppCon 2014: Herb Sutter "Back to the Basics! Essentials of Modern C++ Style" · CppCon · 1:40:26
- CppCon 2015: Kate Gregory “Stop Teaching C" · CppCon · 1:00:11
- Edwin Brady - Idris 2 - Type-driven Development of Idris · Curry On! · 40:38
- Eric Bier Demonstrates Cedar · Computer History Museum · 1:56:07
- CppCon 2016: Herb Sutter “Leak-Freedom in C++... By Default.” · CppCon · 1:39:25
- CppCon 2016: Dan Saks “extern c: Talking to C Programmers about C++” · CppCon · 1:36:26
- "A Political History of X" - Keith Packard (LCA 2020) · linux.conf.au · 45:33
- CppCon 2017: Kate Gregory “10 Core Guidelines You Need to Start Using Now” · CppCon · 1:02:33
- CppCon 2015: Herb Sutter "Writing Good C++14... By Default" · CppCon · 1:29:05
- Yesterday's Computer of Tomorrow: The Xerox Alto │Smalltalk-76 Demo · Computer History Museum · 16:48