Maybe Not - Rich Hickey

Channel:ClojureTV · Length:1:03:28 · Published:2018-11-30 · Views:181667

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Rich Hickey's Clojure/Conj 2018 keynote argues that Maybe/Option types and rigid type signatures are a poor way to model data that changes over time. He builds the case around optionality, schema growth and compatibility, and presents the ideas behind Clojure spec as an alternative.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters send people to it whenever nulls, Maybe/Option or static typing come up, as a thoughtful dissent from the type-system orthodoxy that changes how some people model data.

Rich Hickey's "Maybe Not" should be watched by anyone who thinks nulls/nils/undefineds are okay. — HN, 2018

Programming language design · Functional programming

Subtitles (excerpt)

thank you hi every can here we all right once again it's wonderful to see everybody here a lot of friends how many people have been here every time how people is the first time nice all right how many newlyweds yes oh yeah that's awesome all right before I get started you know there's been a lot of controversy about what we're working on how much working on it and roadmaps and I hope it's evident to everyone this week what we've been working on it's our fashion sense and and I'm happy to announce tonight with the caveat that you know things can change and also that you know this is completely up to me but the roadmap the five-year roadmap for closure is going to be stripes and because I know you've seen enough of my purple shirt but and and if we get enough time to work on it and again no guarantees we've done some experiments of work already but we may work on scarves okay actually we have been working on a ton of stuff and it is mostly getting spoken about at the cons but the thing we didn't quite out in time for cons was 110 but it represents a ton of work and in particular it represents a ton of work by someone who is not going to speak well you just heard speak but I would really like

On Hacker News

My mind blown experience was listening to a Rich Hickey talk (maybe not [1]) that flipped upside down my accepted method of thinking about types and type system paradigms. I still love writing Haskell and Rust, but I see the warts that he is so concisely pointing out. The either type really sticks out to me now, and I see the problems with overtyping what are essentially maps, and how rigid that … — MarkMarine, 2024-11
I bounce back and forth between TypeScript and Clojure. I've been keeping a close eye on Clojure's upcoming spec as it seems to be a nice opt-in, run-time type-checking solution. I like the flexibility and quickness with which dynamic languages let me iterate, but I want the safety. I want at least some of the benefits of both. So yes, they (dynamically typed languages) have some advantages. Some… — vga805, 2019-01
Rich Hickey's "Maybe Not" should be watched by anyone who thinks nulls/nils/undefineds are okay. It should also be watched by anyone who think that Optional/Maybe/Nullable and good enough: [VIDEO] — gambler, 2018-12
"Maybe Not" by Rich Hickey: [VIDEO] Another excellent talk by the creator of Clojure, and like the previous ones, relevant for all programmers. — ttiurani, 2018-12
While we're talking about this conference, rich hickey just changed how I think about domain modelling forever with this talk, released about an hour ago: [VIDEO] Strongly recommend a watch particularly if you're modelling something in a typed language — slifin, 2018-11

Related videos