Line Goes Up – The Problem With NFTs
Channel:Folding Ideas · Length:2:18:23 · Published:2022-01-21 · Views:19072478
Summary
Dan Olson's roughly two-hour video essay critiques NFTs, cryptocurrency, and Web3, covering their technical, economic, and ideological flaws. It is heavily sourced and ends with the advice to ask whether a project needs crypto to work.
Why HN recommends it
It is the go-to long-form critique of crypto that HN commenters recommend whenever skeptics ask for a thorough, well-researched takedown.
probably the most detailed and incisive critique of cryptocurrency and NFTs that I've seen — HN, 2022
Cryptography · Tech industry & business models · Media, journalism & propaganda
Subtitles (excerpt)
for online content creators the unavoidable subject of 2021 has been nfts from incredibly cringeworthy ape profile picks to incomprehensibly tasteless tributes to deceased celebrities to sixf figure sales of the original copy of a meme it is the thing that is currently dominating the collective brain space of digital artists and sucking up all the oxygen in the room and I do want to talk about that I want to talk about my opinions on nfts and digital ownership and scarcity and all the Myriad dimensions of the issue but I don't just want to talk about nfts I can't just talk about nfts because ultimately they are just as symbol of so much more and it is that more that is ultimately important so let me tell you a story in 2008 the economy functionally collapsed the basic chain reaction was this Banks came up with a thing called a mortgage back security a financial instrument that could be traded or collected that was based on a bundle of thousands of individual mortgages based on the general reluctance of banks to issue mortgages the risk aversion in lending someone hundreds of thousands of dollars that they'll pay off over the course of potentially decades these Bonds were seen as especially stable
On Hacker News
Not my favorite video from Dan Olson but still enjoyable. I highly recommend his video about NFTs, Line Goes Up: [VIDEO] So much time, energy, and resources wasted on this stuff when we have such bigger issues to solve as a collective. — mostlysimilar, 2023-03
I've watched the video as well and wholeheartedly agree! His 'Line Goes Up' documentary about crypto is also exceptional; very critical but in educated and actually nuanced ways ( [VIDEO] ). — andreyk, 2022-10
They pretty much nailed it in the last paragraph... > Writing in the New York Times Adrian Chen noted as far back as 2013 that Bitcoin is built on a weird mix of speculative greed bolstered by a utopian cyberlibertarian ideology and likened it to a digital gold rush. Indeed, hyperbole continues to characterise all aspects of the crypto world. Crypto messaging does not appear to be directed at the… — crispyambulance, 2022-02
Folding Ideas' new (2 hour podcast-ish) video "The Problem With NFTs" is a really good critique of cryptocurrency: [VIDEO] Covers pretty much every thought I've ever had regarding centralization, privacy issues, proof of work and proof of stake both rewarding the rich, economic incentives in speculative markets, NFT hucksterism — but with detailed research and examples of each. Some of the NFT se… — code_biologist, 2022-01
On this note. This recent video is probably the most detailed and incisive critique of cryptocurrency and NFTs that I've seen: [VIDEO] It not only covers the technical limitations, but also the ideological flaws. — AlexandrB, 2022-01
Related videos
- CppCon 2019: Matt Godbolt “Compiler Explorer: Behind The Scenes” · CppCon · 1:00:21
- Twitter and Visual Studio Rant · Molly Rocket · 38:19
- Arithmetic, Population and Energy - a talk by Al Bartlett · lXlSalemlXl · 1:14:45
- CppCon 2016: Nicholas Ormrod “The strange details of std::string at Facebook" · CppCon · 31:18
- The Forgotten Art of Structured Programming - Kevlin Henney [C++ on Sea 2019] · cpponsea · 1:29:27
- LISA11 - Fork Yeah! The Rise and Development of illumos · USENIX · 1:04:03
- How big is a visible photon? · Huygens Optics · 20:33
- CppCon 2015: Andrei Alexandrescu “std::allocator...” · CppCon · 1:12:27
- BOLTR: Juicero, Cold Press Juicer for Rich Weirdos · AvE · 41:39
- Every Ruler Makes the Same Mistake When They Die · CGP Grey · 5:38
- Plenary: Performance Matters - Emery Berger - CppCon 2020 · CppCon · 1:01:08
- [EPILEPSY WARNING] How fast should an unoptimized terminal run? · Molly Rocket · 51:03
- Refterm Lecture Part 1 - Philosophies of Optimization · Molly Rocket · 18:41
- How Big is Graham's Number? (feat Ron Graham) · Numberphile · 8:23
- Jim Jefferies -- Gun Control (Part 1) from BARE -- Netflix Special · Jim Jefferies · 7:47
- Why don't Americans use electric kettles? · Technology Connections · 24:55
- The Closest Thing We Have to Alien Technology · Veritasium · 55:00
- Refterm v2 - Resource usage, binary splat, glyph sizing, and more · Molly Rocket · 29:51
- Brick Assembly · Ancient · 12:27
- The Only Unbreakable Law · Molly Rocket · 53:25