AR15: Mud Test

Channel:InRangeTV · Length:5:03 · Published:2016-01-07 · Views:1310395

Watch on YouTube

Summary

InRangeTV subjects an AR-15 to a mud test in the same mud and location as a preceding AK-47 test. It shows how the rifle runs when covered in mud.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in AR versus AK reliability debates as evidence that the AR-15 handles mud better than its reputation suggests.

the purported advantages of AK action over its competitors in this regard are rather drastically overstated in popular culture — HN, 2024

Military history & warfare · Mechanical & precision engineering

Subtitles (excerpt)

Hey guys welcome to another episode of InRange and the continuing Saga of mud testing. We have an AR-15 US GI aluminum magazine with a green follower you can't see that, but it's a standard US GI magazine This is a BCM upper it happens to have a quad rail on it But it's a quality BCM upper, a spikes tactical bolt carrier group and a GWACS lower with a US GI trigger group So we're going to start clean, well, clean as we can be, nothing in the gun And we're going to fire a couple rounds to prove that it works and then we're going to move on to the mud. You know nobody thinks an the AR-15 can pass this test. I've... I've heard that rumor. Alright, so five rounds, ready? On safe, I'm going to close the dust cover for the initial test. And I want to mention something. There's no rear sight here I know there's no rear sight, before you call us an idiot. We're not shooting at a Target This is a mud test, not an accuracy test. We ready? [yep] [There it goes] In the mud That's pretty good? [That's pretty nasty, let's get some on the other side.] [That's the sign that matters] It is. You ready? [yep. Oh yeah, pile it on.] [Little more.] [There we go] It's pretty soupy. [That is very soupy.] I can see stuff

On Hacker News

Both "Forgotten Weapons" and "In Range" are fantastic. Forgotten Weapons introduced me to a lot of firearms history of which I was totally unaware. Things like the Liberator[1] and 2-Bore rifles[2], although with the latter, I'm going to assume that you're hunting smaller naval vessels and/or low-rise buildings. Or you're looking for the fastest possible way to bruise the hell out of your shoulde… — donw, 2020-09
It should be noted that the purported advantages of AK action over its competitors in this regard are rather drastically overstated in popular culture. E.g. take a look at these two vids showing how AK vs AR-15 handle lots of mud: [LINK] [VIDEO] As far as cleaning, AK, like many guns of that era, carries its own cleaning & maintenance toolkit inside the gun. Although it is a bit unusual in that r… — int_19h, 2024-12
> Compare that to an ultra precise AR-15, if you get a little dirt in it, it begins to malfunction. That 'ultra-precise machining' does have some advantages, though: InRangeTV simulated whether a weapon will still work if it gets covered in mud. Originally they tried doing this buy having a guy crawl around in the mud; later, they realised they could just drop mud on the weapon. AKM [LINK] AR-15 … — rgoulter, 2023-04
What's "fetish" about the M16 series? It merely makes different compromises than AK. And some of them ended up working better long-term - e.g. the split receiver makes optics easier to mount, and the gas system and the charging handle placement make the receiver much better sealed against dirt and such. The difference in ruggedness and reliability between the two is also very overstated - much of… — int_19h, 2022-10
>You have to remember to close it after firing You actually don't ( [VIDEO] ). The trick is that the bolt carrier itself seals the action so mud doesn't get into it; most other modern rifles eschew the dust cover entirely and just rely on this. It seems to work pretty well since they keep doing it. — qball, 2022-08

Related videos