How Bankrupt American Cities Stay Alive - Debt [ST04]

Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:11:01 · Published:2021-04-05 · Views:2026599

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Not Just Bikes explains how many American suburbs, built all at once rather than incrementally, cannot cover their infrastructure costs and survive on growing debt. It draws on Strong Towns' work on the growth Ponzi scheme.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as an introduction to the finances of suburban sprawl and its long-term consequences.

I highly recommend this video on the finances around urban sprawl and their long term consequences — HN, 2022

Macroeconomics & financial crises · Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

This is the fourth video in my Strong Towns series. You probably want to watch at least the last two videos to properly understand this one. When some people see the growth ponzi scheme graph for the first time, they may ask, “We’ve been building car-dependent sprawl since the 1950s. Why are the suburbs still here? Shouldn’t they all have gone bankrupt by now?” And it’s a completely reasonable question. Of course, there have been cities in the US that have gone bankrupt. Detroit, Michigan is the example most people think of, but there have been several others, such as Vallejo, California, or Jefferson County Alabama. And Washington Park, Illinois and Moffett, Oklahoma have declared bankruptcy twice. But before you jump on any of these particular examples, you should know that only 27 states even allow municipalities to declare bankruptcy, and of those 15 have special conditions or limitations. So bankruptcies are not telling the whole story. https://www.governing.com/archive/state-municipal-bankruptcy-laws-policies-map.html Nevertheless, most car-dependent places are still here, so why is this? Before we get into the answer to that question, let’s talk about how American cities used to be built.

On Hacker News

Well, this is exactly the opposite to an urban environment - this is urban sprawl. Is it better to construct and maintain 75 miles of roads (and all the other infrastructure) for a couple of hundred folks? I highly recommend this video on the finances around urban sprawl and their long term consequences: [VIDEO] — donjoe, 2022-01
The Not Just Bikes [1,2,3] YouTube channel also has an excellent series of videos based on work from Strong Towns. I link to these videos whenever a friend asks why I chose to leave the United States. :) [1] [VIDEO] [2] [LINK] [3] [LINK] — benrbray, 2021-07
In large parts of the United States it should affect single-family homes. A lot of cities constructed their suburbs with one-term fees and subsidies, but are charging extremely low taxes on the houses once constructed. In fact, the taxes are so low that they don't pay for the upkeep of the infrastructure required to service those houses. They are losing money on every house and are trying to make… — crote, 2024-06
Child safety and cars sure is related - and history buffs will be glad to know the “kindermoord” of automobiles was what got the Netherlands to change from car-centric cities with many lanes wide traffic jams, to the best city infrastructure in the world [LINK] Cars produce crazy noise pollution, and car lifestyle requires massive subsidies such as street parking, and a huge share of city real es… — jeofken, 2022-09
There's no "cannot", it's a conscious choice - if you have more space than necessary that absolutely does not require that you expand to fill all of it. And in particular this has caused issues because American cities tend towards sprawl, filling up area with low-density housing that requires significantly more infrastructure per capita, and implementing zoning laws to prevent higher-density deve… — orn688, 2022-01

Related videos