The Next Major RTS Will Fail. This Is Why.
Channel:GiantGrantGames · Length:25:09 · Published:2022-03-20 · Views:987726
Summary
A video essay arguing that the next major real-time strategy game will fail unless it gets the fundamentals right. It covers the playerbase and demographics, what older RTS games did well, and the roles of the engine, spectacle, development tools and player-generated content.
Why HN recommends it
HN recommends it for its argument that single-player campaigns and modding are overlooked in RTS design.
makes a compelling case for why single-player campaign and mod-development experiences are often overlooked — HN, 2023
Game design · Indie game development · Gaming culture & analysis
Subtitles (excerpt)
Real-time strategy just isn't popular anymore. Players much prefer MOBAs, shooters, and Battle Royale. And developers will never invest in making one. There's no way to monetize it. No loot boxes or season passes. When a new title releases, it comes and goes with little fanfare. The player base dissipates in a few months. It can't sustain competitive ladder, and the game dies. RTS is a relic of gaming's past. As a content creator, I hear people say these things a lot when talking about the future of RTS. And honestly, I think they're full of it. People love to call doom and gloom. It's an easy alternative to critical thinking and analysis. People who remember the good old days of sitting on the gilded throne as the king of esports declaring that all is lost and the world has left them behind. While I disagree on their diagnosis, why? They are correct about one thing. New RTS releases have been consistently bombing. I'm going to argue that the core problem with RTS right now stems not from the players, but from the developers. There's been a fundamental design philosophy shift for RTS. Developers and publishers have lost vision on what makes these games so much fun to play. And if they don't change course, they are destined to a fate of mediocrity at
On Hacker News
GiantGrantGames on Youtube made an interesting video about "The Next Major RTS Will Fail. This is Why"[0]. Turns out he got a lot of this information because he was one of the players that had a huge influence in the development, and this is what ZeroSpace focused their development efforts on. One of which, is targeting the casual audience, and their love for a good story. [0]: [VIDEO] — ixwt, 2024-01
Giant Grant Games makes a compelling case for why single-player campaign and mod-development experiences are often overlooked but are key for RTS crossover success. And this came out long before the success of BG3. I hold out hope that someone will crack the formula! [VIDEO] — btown, 2023-10
In my stumbling around YouTube in the past week, I found "The Next Major RTS Will Fail. This Is Why" - [VIDEO] The publishers have listened to their hard core players - and created games for them. Is Diablo III for the people doing seasons? or the people who play through the campaign in solo mode? With modern games, this in turn means that the casual to competitive conversion rate is low (because… — shagie, 2024-02
Related videos
- How We Made MuseScore 4 - Music App Design is Challenging! · Tantacrul · 46:33
- CheerpX: a WebAssembly-based x86 virtual machine in the browser, Yuri Iozzelli · WebAssembly NA · 37:10
- NaN Gates and Flip FLOPS · suckerpinch · 19:07
- The Closest Thing We Have to Alien Technology · Veritasium · 55:00
- "Turning the database inside out with Apache Samza" by Martin Kleppmann · Strange Loop Conference · 47:42
- This Invention Made Disney MILLIONS, but Then They LOST It! · Corridor Crew · 12:25
- Building The World's First Computer - Greeks, Clocks and Rockets - Antikythera Mechanism Episode 1 · Clickspring · 6:52
- EPC2018 | Wave Function Collapse in Bad North | Oskar Stalberg · BUas Games · 37:41
- Music Software & Bad Interface Design: Avid’s Sibelius · Tantacrul · 21:35
- The Continuity of Splines · Freya Holmér · 1:13:50
- In Search Of A Flat Earth · Folding Ideas · 1:16:16
- Juice it or lose it - a talk by Martin Jonasson & Petri Purho · grapefrukt · 15:38
- This Is Phil Fish · Innuendo Studios · 19:05
- Jan Willem Nijman - Vlambeer - "The art of screenshake" at INDIGO Classes 2013 · Dutch Game Garden · 44:09
- Preventing the Collapse of Civilization / Jonathan Blow (Thekla, Inc) · DevGAMM · 1:02:41
- Jonathan Blow - How to program independent games - CSUA Speech · Alexandre Franco · 1:15:50