How Apple authorized repair refurbishes Macbooks to fail again! GPU kernel panics
Channel:Louis Rossmann · Length:11:34 · Published:2018-05-21 · Views:338469
Summary
Louis Rossmann examines a 2012 MacBook Pro logic board that Apple refurbished for GPU failures and that failed again. He criticizes the quality of Apple's authorized repair work and argues for right to repair.
Why HN recommends it
Cited in threads about Apple repair and refurbishment as evidence of poor refurbishing, with a warning that Rossmann uses colorful language.
Repair, teardowns & right to repair
Subtitles (excerpt)
so when we take a look you can see that this is one of those Apple reefer boards and oh my god if that is not some of the worst resawing I've ever seen in my life Wow really well take a look at this you 8900 Apple reefer board look at that look at those solder joints it's good that's oh my god they say that we don't know what we're doing holy crap look at this the [ __ ] is this what are these joints what is this there's a rate that you call this a really really really Tim Cook we can't we are not authorized we don't know how to refurbish stuff this is how you refurbish it you put a [ __ ] rubber pad on top of you you put a rubber pad on the chip so that the chip gets pushed against the machine onto the board to apply so the whole point of this is to apply pressure to the chip because the issue is that the the the solder joints go bad so if when you tap on this chip which is for the GPU buck converter you're kind of pushing it and wedging it into the board and it'll work nicely again now the boards that have been refurbished by Apple under their program because I'll show you a picture of it here they had a program where they were refurbishing these boards up until December of 2016 for graphics failures this is what they did what
On Hacker News
Louis Rossman has two videos discussing (and showing the boards of) refurbished Apple laptops. I imagine the quality varies depending on the third party who does the refurbishing. The videos contain some colorful language. [VIDEO] [LINK] — andrei_says_, 2021-11
But you do know that apple authorized service center service is often worse because instead of reflowing components they go for stuffing your device with shoe rubber to push chips with defective connections tighter to the pcb? [VIDEO] — rasz, 2023-09
>Asking manufacturers to stock and sell the individual ICs they use to build products is completely untenable. We can settle at not forcing IC manufacturers into contracts prohibiting third part sales. >Machine assembly and factory validation is best. You mean like the time Apple "factory certified refurbished" by gluing a piece of rubber instead of reflowing detaching ICs? [VIDEO] — rasz, 2021-11
Between 2011 and 2013 Apple had a repair extension program for video issues. This is how they fixed them: [VIDEO] — rootlocus, 2019-04
Related videos
- BOLTR: Juicero, Cold Press Juicer for Rich Weirdos · AvE · 41:39
- Longer-lasting light bulbs: it was complicated · Technology Connections · 33:33
- The REAL Reason McDonalds Ice Cream Machines Are Always Broken · Johnny Harris · 29:45
- A Look Inside Apple's $130 USB-C Cable · Adam Savage’s Tested · 21:52
- BOLTR: DYSON HAIR DRYER. Is it WORTH the MONEY? · AvE · 43:19
- The lamps you're not allowed to have. Exploring the Dubai lamps · bigclivedotcom · 32:17
- Tearing Down the Model T of Our Time - Autoline After Hours 284 · Autoline Network · 1:02:35
- This is why we can't have nice things · Veritasium · 17:30
- Tesla Model 3: Inside & Out - Autoline After Hours 417 · Autoline Network · 1:29:52
- What is Right to Repair? An introduction for curious people. · Louis Rossmann · 13:46
- Apple's Independent Repair Program is a useless PR stunt. · Louis Rossmann · 16:08
- EEVblog #186 - Soldering Tutorial Part 3 - Surface Mount · EEVblog · 39:55
- How I Upgraded My iPhone Memory 800% - in Shenzhen, China · Strange Parts · 31:01
- Horrific USB power supply fault. (Electrocution risk.) · bigclivedotcom · 28:20
- TSP #133 - Keysight UXR 110GHz BW, 256GS/s, 10-bit Real-Time Oscilloscope Teardown & Experiments · The Signal Path · 54:34
- Why I don't use Apple products · Louis Rossmann · 14:09