The Mk8 VW GTI isn't as good as its predecessor. | Revelations with Jason Cammisa | Ep. 11

Channel:Hagerty · Length:14:47 · Published:2021-08-26 · Views:1356263

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Jason Cammisa reviews the 2022 Volkswagen Mk8 GTI and explains why he thinks it is worse than the Mk7. He criticizes aspects such as the capacitive touch controls and the interface.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it in threads on touchscreens versus physical buttons in cars, as an example of an enthusiast's critique of VW's UX.

Here's a good video from Jason Cammisa about the new (at the time) mk8 — HN, 2023

UX & UI design · Cars, EVs & motorcycles

Subtitles (excerpt)

well first obviously I'd like to thank the academy but I really owe my success as an award-winning Automotive journalist to being objective I think one of the key differentiators between me and other journalists is that I'm not married to one particular brand and furthermore objectivity and thus my authority comes from loving all cars equally right I mean anyone who owns a car that they're purporting to review at the end of the day they're just completely full [Music] of like all I IC name plates each new generation of GTI isn't just judged by its badge or against the golf that came before it instead it's often judged against a romanticized notion about what the name plate means and so as a journalist the first thing I have to do is to disclose and then ignore the fact that I've bought two Mark 7 Volkswagen's new and then I bought one for my mom and then I helped 28 of my friends by golfs eglfs GTI Jettas and all TRS but whatever now that that's out of the way let's talk about what makes a GTI any GTI so special a GTI is literally nothing more than a fast golf a golf is literally nothing more than a German economy hatchback what's made the GTI so special in every generation since 1975 some better

On Hacker News

Here's a good video from Jason Cammisa about the new (at the time) mk8: [VIDEO] I had a mk7 and it is the best interior + UX I've seen in a car. Everything is as simple and ergonomic as possible. The volume adjustment is a knob, with soft rubber knurling and indents for feedback. It's not some awful feeling smooth afterthought that you see on certain Toyotas or Hondas. It's not a push button (bee… — deckard1, 2023-12
Unfortunately I think it's more driven by cost motivations. As noted in the Mk8 VW GTI review [1], the interfaces are often straight up awful, this being a particularly bad design. They're the biggest source of complaints/issues shortly after buying, and three years later. Additionally, distractions are already abundant in a vehicle. A crappy user interface, which most are, is a safety concern. A… — DavidPeiffer, 2021-11
> my father-in-law's Mazda... the touch screen doesn't work while driving Sounds like it's an older model, and I can tell you from personal experience Mazda, at least, has learned from their mistakes (regarding touchscreens). I know the 2020 models, and I believe much earlier, have all gone back to physical, tactile buttons. Real buttons, not Volkswagon's stupid, stupid capacitive buttons. Watchi… — 29083011397778, 2021-09
The bizzare thing is that the soft buttons had hardcoded symbols on them! [VIDEO] It was objectively worse than physical buttons, without any advantage at all! — dharmab, 2023-12

Related videos