Richard Feynman on hungry philosophers (or do we see objects or only their light)

Channel:Zero · Length:0:54 · Published:2009-08-18 · Views:271987

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A one-minute clip from Richard Feynman's 1979 Auckland lecture in which he answers whether you see an object or only its light. It is a short, playful take on perception and on the use of philosophy.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it to illustrate Feynman's wry view of philosophical questions and perception.

A cute video of Feynman answering the question of whether you're seeing an object, or only the light from an object, when looking at it — HN, 2017

Fundamental physics · Philosophy & ethics · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

when you are looking at something do you see only light or do you see the object the the question of whether or not when you see something you see only the light or you see the thing you're looking at is one of those Dopey philosophical things that an ordinary person has no difficulty with even the most profound philosopher in sitting eating his dinner has any difficulty making out that what he looks at perhaps might be only the light from the steak but it still implies the existence of the steak which he's able to lift by the fork to his mouth the philosophers that were unable to make that analysis and that idea have have fallen by the wayside through hunger [Applause]

On Hacker News

I dunno about the rest of you, but I clicked on the link to her Twitter account, which so far has much higher quality stuff than this thread on HN. Some fun links: "Lightning makes new isotopes" [LINK] "P-values--abused but not abandoned" (includes some nice background on p-values for those of us for whom the concept is a little fuzzy) [LINK] A cute video of Feynman answering the question of whet… — thaumaturgy, 2017-11
I respect philosophy, but am more persuaded by Richard Feynman's perspective, when asked what he considered a philosophical question. [VIDEO] This NY Times story gets that philosophy isn't that necessary, but then got so bogged down in philosophical writing it was a chore to get through and I don't consider it worth my time to have read it. Socrates said "The unexamined life is not worth living."… — spodek, 2012-01
> It's like proving a negative. "You can't prove a negative" is one of dopey philosophical slogans[1] that are meaningless in practice. It gives undue weight to absolutes that do not exist in reality. The statement "money doesn't grow on trees" is obviously true, yet you can't logically rule out the existence of such a tree. What are the practical implications of this? None. If we tested a hypoth… — incrudible, 2021-07
A parallel in defining words. A word dictionary has to be self referential, or you need an ever increasing vocabulary, or just accept some axioms that don't require verification (you know what a word like cat is by some interaction escaping out of the context of word descriptions) Another parallel [VIDEO] we were computationally evolved to make sense of the world... and making sense is a computat… — downshun, 2020-03
"Western metaphysics typically holds that – in addition to the existence of any thoughts, emotions and physical sensations – there is some entity to whom all these experiences are happening, and that it makes sense to refer to this entity as ‘I’ or ‘me’. However, according to Buddhist philosophy, there is no ‘self’ or ‘me’ to which such phenomena belong." This reminds me of this quip by Richard F… — gridlockd, 2019-07

Related videos