What is a Geometry Kernel? C3D vs ACIS vs Parasolid

Channel:nickkallen1 · Length:9:27 · Published:2022-06-17 · Views:25456

Watch on YouTube

Summary

The Plasticity creator explains what a geometry kernel is and compares commercial options C3D, ACIS, and Parasolid, describing his months of research and why he chose as he did.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in CAD threads as a rare plain-spoken comparison of commercial geometry kernels and their limitations.

Mentions an interesting video[2] going through the commercial geometry kernel options and their resp. limitations — HN, 2023

Computer graphics & rendering · 3D printing, CNC & maker projects

Subtitles (excerpt)

I want to talk today about what is a geometry kernel and why it matters for plasticity. So a geometry kernel is a software library for performing geometric calculations on surfaces and volumes. For example, it can compute the intersection of two surfaces and it can produce a fillet that is a blending surface that is continuous to two adjacent surfaces. In general, these algorithms are extremely difficult to make correct. It takes teams of engineers and mathematicians like dozens of years to make a robust geometry kernel that is useful for like making a car or an airplane or an iPhone or something like that. So historically the kernel industry has been dominated by two products Parasolid and ASUS. Um they both got their start in the early 80s and most popular CAD programs like Solid Works, Space Claim, Shaper 3D use one of these two kernels. Even Fusion 360 uses a descendant of ASUS that Autodesk um forked off 20 years ago. Both ASUS and Parasolid are very powerful and mature, but in certain ways they're also very old-fashioned. I mean, they're literally 40-year-old code bases. And I believe even uh that Parasolid is written in lisp and transpiled to C. And you can see just kind of skimming some of my C++ code interacting with Parasolid

On Hacker News

The creator of this app, Nick Kallen, has a nice YouTube channel where he talks about some of the behind-the-scenes work on the project. I think his video comparing geometry kernels [0] was posted to HN a while back, but it's worth a watch if you're curious! [0]: [VIDEO] — awhitty, 2024-03
Nick Kallen has been working on an BREP based CAD tool with the sort of ease of modeling that things like Blender has. Originally it was based on C3D, but he switched halfway through to Parasolid.[0] It’s amazing the amount of features he has built considering it’s a one person project. It’s worth going through his progress report videos.[1] [0] [VIDEO] [1] [LINK] — s1mon, 2023-02
See also this thread[1] from yesterday which has some interesting comments on the limitations projects based on the OpenCascade kernel face. Mentions an interesting video[2] going through the commercial geometry kernel options and their resp. limitations from the author of [3]. [1] [LINK] [2] [VIDEO] [3] [LINK] — virtualritz, 2023-02
The other "decent" commercial one that can be licensed is C3D (ASCON/АСКОН uses a CAD kernel based on it in КОМПАС 3D) but it is Russian and thus currently "behind sanctions". Here is a bit on it from the author of Plasticity: [VIDEO] it initially was based on C3D. — ruevs, 2025-06

Related videos