What keeps a train on the track?

Channel:BoreMeScience · Length:2:27 · Published:2009-09-22 · Views:190711

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short clip of Richard Feynman explaining how a train stays on its tracks, through the conical shape of wheels and how it handles curves without differentials.

Why HN recommends it

HN links it as a great, surprising explanation whenever rail wheels, gauge or curves come up.

Here's a great explanation by Richard Feynman — HN, 2020

Fundamental physics · Transit, cities & urban planning · Mechanical & precision engineering

Subtitles (excerpt)

a harder one and very entertaining was what keeps a train on the track and of course the answer is as everyone thinks the flanges on the wheels you know the wheels have some kind of flange on them but that's not the answer those flanges just safety devices if the fledges rub against the tracks you hear a terrible squealing they just in case the real mechanism doesn't work there's another problem with trains that's connected to it that people all know about their automobile that when you go around the corner the outside Wheels have to go further than the inside wheels and if the front if the wheels were connected on a solid shaft you couldn't do that you can't turn the outside Wheels further than the inside wheels and so the Sha is broken in the Middle with a gear system it's called a differential did you ever see the differential on a railroad train no you look at those wheels under a freight car and there are the two wheels and there's a solid steel Rod going from one wheel to the other there's nothing One turns the same as the other so now how does it go around a corner a curve when the outside wheel has to go further than the inside wheel and the answer is that the wheels are flanged like this I mean not

On Hacker News

> unlike the cylindrical profile which again just steers with the flange basically rubbing against the edge of the railhead. That's crazy. That means that the wheels are actually slipping when going around a corner, because the wheels are all the same diameter. Unlike conical wheels, which are essentially self-steering. Here's a great explanation by Richard Feynman: [VIDEO] How could the BART tra… — frosted-flakes, 2020-06
[VIDEO] (video of Feynman explaining how trains stay on the track) Is this it? I found it in my YouTube history. Or this one, which superimposes free body diagram (of forces) on the wheels to show how it is self stabilizing? [LINK] — texaslonghorn5, 2022-07
Snopes rates it as partly true, and the author is a pedantic killjoy. It is broadly true that for 2000 years European vehicles matched their roads and adapting existing vehicles to new technology led to using axles that were the same size. Do other gauges exist? Of course. Are the true elements of this worth repeating? Sure. As an unrelated aside here’s Richard Feynman explaining why train axles … — JackFr, 2019-06

Related videos