The Disaster That Changed Engineering: The Hyatt Regency Collapse
Channel:Tom Scott · Length:4:20 · Published:2017-03-13 · Views:2678588
Summary
A Tom Scott guest video by Grady Hillhouse of Practical Engineering on the 1981 Hyatt Regency walkway collapse. A seemingly minor change to the support design led to catastrophic failure, which is why the case is taught as a lesson to check and double-check everything.
Why HN recommends it
HN cites it as the standard case study of how a small unchecked design change causes disaster, and of why engineering process and bureaucracy exist.
Grady from Practical Engineering has a great explainer of what went wrong — HN, 2021
Civil engineering & construction
Subtitles (excerpt)
Today’s guest video is from Grady at Practical Engineering. He’s talking about a tragedy: and the lessons we learned and the reasons why it happened are fascinating. Also, he made his own props. Grady, take it away. In the summer of 1981, the Hyatt Regency Hotel in Kansas City, Missouri, hosted a large party in the multi-story atrium area. During the event, suspended walkways on the second and fourth floors collapsed, killing over 100 people and injuring over 200 more. At the time, the accident was the worst structural failure in US history. In the wake of the disaster, investigators discovered a change to the original design of the walkways that was proposed by the fabricator and mistakenly approved by the structural engineer. What, at first glance, seemed like a subtle adjustment to the design, turned out to be the root cause of the failure. Two suspended walkways spanned the atrium in the Hyatt Regency with the second-floor walkway directly below the fourth-floor walkway. Each was supported by a series of box girders suspended by hanger rods and retained by nuts and washers. The original design called for a single pair of hanger rods, which would pass through each fourth-floor girder to the second-floor girder below.
On Hacker News
... buildings don't fall all of sudden... False. Large structural failures can be catastrophic and unexpected. Buildings can and do collapse quite suddenly. The examples here are not necessarily caused by reinforced concrete failures (though several cases make use of reinforced concrete --- generally other failures lead to the collapse). But the final failure of a system under load and near its s… — dredmorbius, 2021-05
False premise. Building failures occur all the time. By relative frequency, not so often: physical structures are simpler, tangible, better understood. But they still fail often. [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] In 1st-world countries as well: [LINK] [LINK] [VIDEO] — dredmorbius, 2020-04
They do think of that. I've seen old bridges where extra barriers had been installed to prevent the full width being used because it was judged not capable of supporting the weight of being filled with people by modern standards. On the other hand, sometimes it all goes wrong: [VIDEO] — jonp888, 2018-11
Yeah I could imagine an article coming from the opposite direction, deriding ivory tower calculations in favor of real world experimentalism in some case where the developers didn't do enough physical testing. There are definitely plenty of cases where design mistakes have been unaddressed to tragic consequences: poor modeling in the Hyatt Regency collapse ( [VIDEO] ), underspecified gusset plate… — steamer25, 2018-07
The case-study of the Hyatt Regency collapse might a major root cause of the bureaucracy you're describing. The change that caused the issue was approved by the engineers in that case, but I think made us a lot more instituionally cautious: * [LINK] * [VIDEO] — lkbm, 2017-05
Related videos
- Introduction: The Chemical History of a Candle by Michael Faraday (1/6) · engineerguy · 3:19
- Do Chairs Exist? · Vsauce · 37:53
- The Perfect Sourdough Pizza (Bread Porn) · LifebyMikeG · 6:46
- Every Melody Has Been Copyrighted (and they're all on this hard drive) · Adam Neely · 10:32
- The GUI should be better. A lot better. · Accursed Farms · 1:17:21
- Mike Monteiro - "Fuck you pay me" (PT Br) · Montalvo Machado · 38:40
- Mastering the Vim Language · thoughtbot · 36:19
- College Lecture Series - Neil Postman - "The Surrender of Culture to Technology" · College of DuPage · 1:25:11
- The Most IMPORTANT Video You'll Ever See (part 1 of 8) · wonderingmind42 · 9:17
- re:publica 2015 - Aral Balkan: Beyond The Camera Panopticon · re:publica · 1:03:13
- The Secret History of Silicon Valley · Google TechTalks · 56:32
- Stroads are Ugly, Expensive, and Dangerous (and they're everywhere) [ST05] · Not Just Bikes · 18:13
- 1. How Buildings Learn - Stewart Brand - 1 of 6 - “Flow” · Stewart Brand · 29:36
- What Really Happened During the Texas Power Grid Outage? · Practical Engineering · 16:47
- Orbital Rings · Isaac Arthur · 30:36
- Building a Cathedral without Science or Mathematics: The Engineering Method Explained · engineerguy · 11:54