Flanders & Swann - 'First And Second Law'

Channel:notsyort · Length:4:21 · Published:2013-02-14 · Views:258074

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Flanders and Swann perform 'First and Second Law', a comic song about the laws of thermodynamics, from their 1964 stage show At the Drop of Another Hat. It sets the first and second laws to a deadpan call-and-response routine.

Why HN recommends it

HN brings it up whenever thermodynamics or entropy comes up, as the classic comic explanation of the laws.

The classic Flanders and Swann explanation — HN, 2024

Fundamental physics · Stand-up & sketch comedy · Music performance & songs

Subtitles (excerpt)

One of the great problems of the world today is undoubtedly this problem of not being able to talk to scientists because we don't understand science. They can't talk to us because they don't understand anything else, poor dears. This problem, I think it was C.P. Snow first raised it, Sir Charles Snow in private life. And in his in his books Science and Government and so on. Mind you, I haven't read it. I'm I'm waiting for the play to come. He says quite rightly, he says he said it's no good going up to a scientist and saying to him as you would to anybody else, you know, good morning, how are you? Lend me a quid and so on. He mean you just you just glare at you. Or make a rude retort or something. You have to speak to him in language that he'll understand. I mean you go up to him, you say something like um Ah, H2SO4, Professor. Don't Don't synthesize anything I wouldn't synthesize. Oh. Oh, and and the reciprocal of pi to your good wife. Now, this This he will understand. Snow says that nobody can consider themselves educated who doesn't know at least the basic language of science. I mean things like Sir Edward Boyle's law, for example. The greater the external pressure, the greater the volume of hot air.

On Hacker News

The classic Flanders and Swann explanation: [VIDEO] Excerpts: No one can consider themsleves educated who doesn't understand the basic language of science - Boyle's law: the greater the external pressure the greater the volume of hot air. I was someone shocked to learn my partner not only doesn't understand the 2nd law of thermodynamics, he doesn't even understand the first! : Heat won't pass fro… — robaato, 2024-07
> While they don't have the science/maths background that makes Lehrer an obvious win for the HN crowd, True, but they did one on thermodynamics [VIDEO] — ska, 2024-05
"Heat cannot of itself pass from one body to a hotter body." Thank you, Flanders and Swann! [VIDEO] — chrisatthestudy, 2023-05
The claim is that the walls can be hotter than the room around it. By the second law of thermodynamics, heat doesn't naturally move from a cooler object to a hotter object, or as Flanders and Swann would put it, "heat don't move from a cooler to a hotter" ( [VIDEO] ) [1] — ajb, 2020-08

Related videos