The Only* Car-Free Neighbourhood in Canada (and why you can't live there)

Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:14:18 · Published:2022-04-04 · Views:1093129

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Not Just Bikes visits the Toronto Islands, home to Canada's only car-free neighbourhood. He explains the waiting list and strict ownership rules and asks why more such places aren't built.

Why HN recommends it

Used as a concrete example of what a car-free neighbourhood looks like and of the demand for them.

— HN, 2023

Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

There aren’t a lot of car-free places left in the world. Cars have inserted themselves pretty much everywhere, even in places where they really shouldn’t fit. I'm looking at you, every old city in Italy and many of the places that couldn't be paved over have become tourist attractions, like Venice. Of course, when people think about those few car-free places remaining, they probably think about the old city centres of Europe. But what might surprise you is that you’ll find a car-free neighbourhood right in the heart of Canada’s largest city. This is Toronto, and just off the coast of downtown is a chain of 15 small car-free islands. By the way, when I say “car free”, I mean approximately zero cars, not exactly zero cars. Like the Duch concept of autoluw. But, more about that later. The Toronto Islands are only accessible by ferry to one of three destinations: Ward’s Island, Centre Island, and Hanlan’s Point The ferry ride to the island costs $8.50 and leaves from the downtown ferry terminal, named after socialist politician Jack Layton, who was actually a pretty good guy, especially for a politician. Look him up some time He helped to invent this kind of bike rack, which is now the standard all around Toronto.

On Hacker News

> Cities are welcome to erect whatever barriers they like to private cars. [VIDEO] "The real problem is that we couldn’t build another place like this if we wanted to. It’s not allowed. It’s literally illegal in Canada, to build something like this today." — mitthrowaway2, 2024-03
You're comparing living in a car dependant city vs living in car dependant suburbs. It's not going to be meaningfully different. You mention the constant noise, but what do you think causes it? To see what everyone means by car dependency, you'd need to see the few places that aren't. Here's what a 100% car-free island looks like: [VIDEO] Here are some progressive European cities that have starte… — Mawr, 2023-11
> I’m not convinced that will ever change unless sprawl becomes unimaginably expensive. Right, but that's the core of my point: It is unimaginably expensive, it's just getting subsidized to ridiculous extents. (For the readers unaware of this: [LINK] ) And saying the "vast majority" prefer it is wrong. They prefer it over the alternatives they have within the United States , not over the alternat… — scrollaway, 2022-07

Related videos