Renting vs. Buying a Home: The 5% Rule
Channel:Ben Felix · Length:10:36 · Published:2019-05-11 · Views:5320687
Summary
Ben Felix explains how to compare renting and buying a home by looking at unrecoverable costs, and distills it into the 5% rule of thumb. It is framed for a Canadian audience but broadly applicable.
Why HN recommends it
HN points to it for a clean first-order framework for the rent versus buy decision.
This guy breaks down the analysis very cleanly to a first-order approximation, using 2019 figures — HN, 2026
Subtitles (excerpt)
- I have talked about the decision around renting versus buying a home before. But in this video I wanted to take a bit of a different angle. The common perception is that if you can purchase a home with a mortgage payment that is equal to or less than what you would otherwise pay in rent then buying is a good decision. This way of thinking about the rent versus buy decision is extremely flawed. Comparing a mortgage payment to rent is not an apples to apples comparison. In order to properly assess the rent versus buy decision, we need to compare the total unrecoverable costs of renting to the total unrecoverable costs of owning. That may sound like a complicated task but I have boiled it down to a simple calculation. I'm Ben Felix, portfolio manager at PWL Capital. In this episode of "Common Sense Investing" I'm going to give you a simple way to think about the rent versus buy decision. (upbeat music) Before we get to the 5% rule, I need to lay out the assumptions that have gone into it. An unrecoverable cost is a cost that you pay with no associated residual value. When we are talking about the total unrecoverable cost of renting, the number is very easy. It's just the amount that you're paying in rent.
On Hacker News
Ben Felix, a Canadian portfolio manager that does personal finance videos and podcast, has been arguing for years that rent versus buy is often a wash financially, and that you should make the decision for non-financial resasons. * recent 2026 video: [LINK] * 2025a: [LINK] * 2025b: [LINK] * 2021: [LINK] * 2019: [VIDEO] The 2019 video goes over a handy "5% rule of thumb": start with the purchase p… — throw0101c, 2026-05
The borrowed money isn't free from interest. There's no numerical sense in borrowing money at 5%+ interest to fund an investment appreciating at 3%. Some schemes might advantage it further (such as leveraging your mortgage with your retirement funds) but then we might as well also discuss further disadvantages compared to renting, such as upkeep and property taxes. Back around 2020 when mortgage … — Paracompact, 2026-05
> You don't need to purchase a home - but historically - if you did - you've been much better off financially. [citation needed] Per the The Credit Suisse Global Investment Returns Yearbook 2018 , the global return for real estate from 1900 to 2017 was 1.3%, while stocks returns 5.2%: * [LINK] Rent is often cheaper than mortgage payments, and is very more often cheaper than mortgage payments plus… — throw0101a, 2022-05
Hi, Australian here living in Sydney. I'm a very happy renter. Renting in Sydney annually is way under 5% of the cost of owning a house. Even if I could afford to buy a house in Sydney, I wouldn't dream of it. It's much more economically sensible to rent. The money I save in opportunity costs from renting is huge. I can invest the difference between rent and mortgage repayments and don't need to … — throwaway9139, 2021-12
I feel like this article could do a better job comparing renting and buying a home, so here's a video I think makes some good arguments about why it's not such a clear decision. [VIDEO] I'd be interested in seeing analysis of how this 3rd option would historically compare to renting and home ownership. — Cicero22, 2021-03
Related videos
- What People Get Wrong About Dense Urban Living · Oh The Urbanity! · 7:09
- What People Get Wrong About Induced Demand · Oh The Urbanity! · 8:04
- Quantum Entanglement & Spooky Action at a Distance · Veritasium · 9:15
- Is AI Safety a Pascal's Mugging? · Robert Miles AI Safety · 13:41
- The Halo Drive · Cool Worlds · 17:33
- Wealth Inequality in America · politizane · 6:23
- I tried using AI. It scared me. · Tom Scott · 15:49
- Feynman: How to think 1 of 2 FUN TO IMAGINE 11 · Christopher Sykes · 6:24
- TUN: Un-Ruining the MMO · MrBtongue · 14:05
- How close is nuclear fusion power? · Sabine Hossenfelder · 12:49
- I Solved Klotski · 2swap · 12:19
- How the Fed's "Money Printer" Really Works · Ben Felix · 18:01
- Stroads are Ugly, Expensive, and Dangerous (and they're everywhere) [ST05] · Not Just Bikes · 18:13
- Who Is Responsible For Climate Change? – Who Needs To Fix It? · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 10:36
- This Video Is Sponsored By ███ VPN · Tom Scott · 7:25
- Distinguished Lecturer Series: Building Science - Adventures in Building Science · Berkeley Lab · 1:09:52
- These Stupid Trucks are Literally Killing Us · Not Just Bikes · 35:07
- Jared Mauch - Getting Fiber To My Town (NLNOG Live! September 2020) · NLNOG · 34:42
- International Diversification · Ben Felix · 10:59
- How does a USB keyboard work? · Ben Eater · 34:15