Cosmos - Carl Sagan - 4th Dimension

Channel:carlsagandotcom · Length:7:23 · Published:2009-03-24 · Views:5442254

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A segment from Carl Sagan's original Cosmos explaining the fourth spatial dimension through analogy with a two-dimensional world and shadow projection.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as the clearest intuitive introduction to thinking about a fourth dimension.

brilliantly exemplified by Carl Sagan in this popular video — HN, 2021

Pure mathematics · Recreational & visual math · Fundamental physics

Subtitles (excerpt)

in discussing the large scale structure of the cosmos astronomers sometimes say that space is curved or that the universe is finite but unbounded whatever are they talking about let's imagine that we are perfectly flat I mean absolutely flat and that we live appropriately enough in a flat land a land designed and named by Edwin Abbott a Shakespearean scholar who lived in Victoria in England everybody in flatland is of course exceptionally flat we have squares circles triangles and we all Scurry about and we can go into our houses and do our flat business now we have width and length but no height at at all now these little cutouts have some little height but let's ignore that let's imagine that these are absolutely flat that being the case we know us Flatlanders about left right and we know about forward back but we have never heard of up down let us imagine that into flatland hovering above it comes a strange three-dimensional creature which oddly enough looks like an apple and the three-dimensional creature sees an attractive congenial looking Square watches it enter its house and decides in a gesture of interdimensional Amity to say hello hello says the three-dimensional creature how are you I am a visitor from

On Hacker News

Good answer, a 4th dimension and the shadow projection analogy is brilliantly exemplified by Carl Sagan in this popular video: [VIDEO] — lgl, 2021-04
In 3 dimensional space, you can’t. Draw a square on paper. The lines will be orthogonal. Draw a cube. The third dimension won’t be orthogonal. It can’t be. But, that doesn’t mean a third dimension doesn’t exist or can’t exist. The same thing happens with a hypercube. The fourth dimension won’t be orthogonal on paper. It won’t be orthogonal in three dimensions (you can build a 3D projection of a h… — travisjungroth, 2024-10
For those trying to wrap their heads around this ... I find this segment by Carl Sagan from the original Cosmos to be pretty well presented on the topic: [VIDEO] — CodeCube, 2014-02
> how weird large-dimensional space is It's rather crazy that we humans can't really even intuit about a single extra dimension. Or even a single fewer! There's a lot of people who will say that they can visualize things in the 4th dimension but I've yet to find someone who can actually do this. This includes a large number of mathematicians (it's never the mathematicians that claim this...) I re… — godelski, 2025-07
A fun way think about it is pressing on a filled balloon from the outside. Inside the balloon is our whole reality/dimension. Everyone is poking inwards and bending the rubber is what we see and how we interact with each other. But we're completely locked into our current senses. In some ways, it sounds awfully... "spiritual", right? The challenge is there's no point in trying to imagine what exi… — vyrotek, 2022-10

Related videos