Rick Reacts to Lightning (Again) and brings up a previously undiscussed flaw

Channel:We Are All Satoshi · Length:25:14 · Published:2018-02-25 · Views:14097

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Rick Falkvinge responds to viewer feedback on his earlier Lightning Network video and raises a flaw he says was not previously discussed. The main thread is the network's unsolved routing problem.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters cite it, with a pointer to the section from about 10:00, when arguing that Lightning has no solved routing algorithm; most mentions are critical of Lightning.

Key bit from 10:00 on, though the rest is well worth your time — HN, 2018

Networking & internet infrastructure · Cryptography

Subtitles (excerpt)

hey guys this is Rick so last week's video on the Lightning Network generated a lot of discussion and I have to admit some of that discussion was quite productive and as it turns out I was slightly off on just where the NA lightning network stands in fact it's much worse than I first thought let's take a look at why so a second look at the Lightning Network following up from last Sunday we were seeing this graph a lot last week as we are talking about routing of payments routing of payments from our system down here into our channel to a destination network somewhere up here and as I Ellis trated there were four problems with this those four problems were that routing was unsolved you must be online to receive which it was argued is less of a problem for web merchants because they must have their website online in the first place which is a fair point the legal liability for nodes they're gonna be subject to know your customer and I'm money laundering regulations because you're locking fund funds up with them and reactive security like in IRC doesn't work but there was a very interesting discussion which followed this specifically about a routing routing and following that discussion I've come to realize that it is much much

On Hacker News

> Dont be an ignorant big blocker. Look at the smartest people in this space. The real technical folk. What are they saying? I'm seeing them zoom in on the key technical problem: at no point has LN fixed the key technical issue, how to route. Every transaction invalidates the routing path, because it changes the amount of liquidity available in the channels. Rick Falkvinge nails this point. Key b… — davidgerard, 2018-02
I think this is the right direction as I think all money is a form of debt - usually coupled with some settlement mechanism. Once we get a good implementation of debt settlement then I think we might actually get a usable decentralised money. As a few comments have pointed out this similar to the Lightening network and Ripple. One comment mentioned that Ripple never found a routing algorithm and … — snthpy, 2019-04
The lightening network inherently suffers from limitations on transaction rates and an inability to scale up. [LINK] It's one of the most basic computer bugs, and LN design is incompatible with a fix for race conditions due to decentralization. There's also the aspect that the Lightening Network's design inevitably turns it into a banking network, designed to extract fees for the wealthy. [VIDEO] — badge, 2018-09
If you understand computer science and design, there are some claims the LN team makes which will never be possible. The lightening network inherently suffers from limitations on transaction rates and an inability to scale up. [LINK] It's one of the most basic computer bugs, and LN design is incompatible with a fix for race conditions due to decentralization. There's also the aspect that the Ligh… — badge, 2018-09
No. The LN white paper doesn't even explain how they plan to solve routing. [VIDEO] Without decentralized routing, It seems like they're simply prioritizing nodes with large sums of BTC as the central operator hubs. Centralized payment processing hubs? — nosuchthing, 2018-03

Related videos