Tesla Autopilot 17.7.2 Fails

Channel:DeRage · Length:25:16 · Published:2017-02-26 · Views:43922

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A driver tests Tesla Model S Autopilot firmware 17.7.2 on hardware 2.0 and records numerous failures, including crossing to the wrong side of the road.

Why HN recommends it

Cited critically as evidence that early Autopilot 2 was unsafe and overpromised.

Self-driving & autonomous vehicles · Cars, EVs & motorcycles

Subtitles (excerpt)

hey guys D raage here so we're going to do a little um autopilot test I did a video yesterday and but I didn't like the point of view so you know I changed my setup a little bit here see if the uh point of view it's a little better for you guys so this road is in the middle of nowhere so and um it's probably going oh look at that act up already you did not know what to do once the lanes uh finish also we're going against the sun right now so we're doing this test good thing there's nobody around us and we're over the line already I don't know if you guys can see that um we found the middle of the right lane now there's this little island over here I don't think it'll be able to negotiate it and look at that it did not negotiate that at all um and obviously I just let that happen because are in the midd of nowhere it's just grass and no Wildlife we harmed we're in a Wildlife Reserve um and there is nobody else around and it can never make this uh turn back so it turns from the island is notices the curb but uh it basically does not find the white line I mean you know for this is a old white line you know kind of like Fad in and stuff but still it should be able to to negotiate this turn um I guess it's it relies a lot on the white line as you guys can see we're

On Hacker News

Your comment made me wonder whether i hadn't miss anything : are car actually able to drive themselves in clear condition at the moment ? I've seen the demos of the start ups in the valley, the local experiments, but i'm still waiting for a single real-world deployment, even limited to local driving, such as city to city taxi driving, or item delivery. On the other hand, i did hear of the trouble… — bsaul, 2017-10
I just saw their latest marketing literature on their website. They promise: > All Tesla vehicles produced in our factory, including Model 3, have the hardware needed for full self-driving capability at a safety level substantially greater than that of a human driver. [LINK] It seems somewhat irresponsible to promise that you have enough hardware to achieve something that nobody has ever achieved… — haberman, 2017-06
Elsewhere on HN, someone posted this video: [VIDEO] This was my comment reply: Wow. That guy is going nineteen miles per hour on a simple road in daylight and the car literally crossed to the wrong side of the road in nine seconds! That's an absolute disaster. — owenversteeg, 2017-04
This is the leaders performance on actual production hardware outside of fancy (postprocessed) videos with their "cameras only" approach: [VIDEO] At this point I don't even care if they theorethically are the best, if they are willing to release this dangerous crap they are sooner going to go up in a big publicity fire than get actual autonomy to customers. — revelation, 2017-04
That's terrible performance. The problem seems to be that Tesla's system is extremely dependent on a nice clear white line at the outer edge of the road. On this road, near the traffic islands, the roadside grass sometimes overgrows the road edge and obscures the white line. The white line has also been scuffed by cars near the edge of the road. [1] The Tesla runs off the road in that situation. … — Animats, 2017-04

Related videos