The Bell Curve

Channel:Shaun · Length:2:39:45 · Published:2019-12-04 · Views:4061627

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Shaun's roughly 2.7-hour video essay on The Bell Curve. It covers intelligence, the g factor, IQ tests, IQ versus environment and the politics behind the book, with a critical reading of the sources.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters most often cite it as a thorough, well-sourced debunking of The Bell Curve and of popular IQ claims.

The video is well-researched; I've been a long-time fan of the creator for putting out quality stuff. — HN, 2020

Social issues & culture · Psychology & human behavior · Evolution & genetics

Subtitles (excerpt)

hello everyone today we're going to be talking about the bell curve the bell curve is a 1994 book by psychologist Richard J Herrnstein and political scientist Charles Murray and by way of an introduction here I'll read the description of the book that's on the back of my copy breaking new ground and old taboos Richard J hansteen and Charles Maurey tell the story of a society in transformation at the top a cognitive elite is forming in which the passkey to the best schools and the best jobs is no longer social background but high intelligence at the bottom the common denominator of the underclass is increasingly low intelligence rather than racial or social disadvantage the bell curve describes the state of scientific knowledge about questions that have been on people's minds for years but have been considered too sensitive to talk about openly among them IQs relationship to crime unemployment welfare child neglect poverty and illegitimate ethnic differences in intelligence trends in fertility among women with different levels of intelligence and what policy can do and cannot do to compensate for differences in intelligence brilliantly argued and meticulously documented the bell curve is the essential first

On Hacker News

[VIDEO] It's a 2 hour video essay that covers psychometry generally as a lens to understanding a book called the Bell Curve that was a flashpoint for questions about the validity of IQ science generally (but most especially how it applies to race). It took a good chunk of my Sunday to get through it, but it was really enjoyable and gave me a ton of insight into a ton of buzzwords and studies I ha… — tjnaylor, 2023-04
This video about the problems with The Bell Curve (a book about IQ and other things) does a lot to explain a lot of the problems with IQ: [VIDEO] . The video is well-researched; I've been a long-time fan of the creator for putting out quality stuff. >and it definitely has a large genetic component There's a number of studies showing that IQ is "heritable", but this is different from saying it's g… — AgentME, 2020-01
Those two assumptions are not particularly well-supported by data or modern thought on capabilities. Even the construct of "IQ" is probably a post-hoc explanation of data rather than a predictive thing. If you want an hours-long discussion of that in the context of the book, The Bell Curve, have a look at: [VIDEO] — pfooti, 2024-11
I think this video by `Shaun` is informative and well-researched (articles and books are cited). It's long; the creator isn't especially succinct, but it's as entertaining as the material allows, and the subject's complex enough to warrant a video that's a couple of hours long. [VIDEO] — geraldalewis, 2023-04
> For most people, performance on one type of cognitive task (e.g. verbal reasoning) is highly correlated with performance on the other types of cognitive tasks. It's cool that that's your understanding, but you're wading into territory that gets people sterilized and killed. I have a lot of trust in science, but not here. This video was informative for me: [VIDEO] For example, here's an IQ test;… — geraldalewis, 2023-04

Related videos