Tom Lehrer - Wernher von Braun - with intro

Channel:The Tom Lehrer Wisdom Channel · Length:2:16 · Published:2009-07-11 · Views:1195082

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Tom Lehrer performs his satirical song about rocket scientist Wernher von Braun, with an introduction, in a short clip posted for the Apollo 11 anniversary. It lampoons von Braun's moral flexibility.

Why HN recommends it

HN brings it up as the sharpest satire of scientists who serve whoever pays them, and as a favorite Lehrer song.

My favourite is Wernher Von Braun. — HN, 2022

Space exploration & spaceflight · Satire & parody · Music performance & songs

Subtitles (excerpt)

well speaking of bombs what is it that makes America the world's greatest nuclear power and what is it that will make it possible for us to spend $20,000 million of our taxpayers money to put some idiot on the moon well it was the great enormous superiority of American Technology of course as provided by our Great American scientists such as Dr verer Von [Music] Brown gather around while I sing you a verer fun Brown a man whose Allegiance is ruled by expedience call him a Nazi he won't even frown Nai says v f don't say that he's hypocritical say rather that he's apolitical once the Rockets are up who cares where they come down that's not my department says [Music] very some have harsh words words for this man of renown but some think our attitude should be one of gratitude like the widows and cripples in Old London Town who owe their large pensions to verer fun Brown you two may be a big hero once you've learned to count backwards to zero in German or English I know how to countown and I'm learning Chinese says vanard F Brown [Applause]

On Hacker News

My favourite is Wernher Von Braun. [VIDEO] Thank you Tom Lehrer for all the memories and the laughs, and a biting satire that's still fresh. — sriram_malhar, 2022-12
Hard to tell, but it was consistently losing to the Soviet Union by most space-dick measurement metrics. Please don't see me as defending the USSR in any way, it's a widely accepted fact that the USSR was 0.5-2 years ahead in most milestones. My comment was more in line to contradict the statement of "this country invented everything!" when obviously the Soviets had a strong know how that certain… — fer, 2021-12
And we've come full circle: your argument here is exactly the same as here: [LINK] I am happy to let you keep showing off your circular reasoning to the world, and will happily repeat myself pointing out all my counterpoints you did not engage with and ignored. For example: - I claimed a technology's existence is enough to cause real world consequences. You ignored this point. - I mentioned you a… — cjslep, 2020-03
Along these lines, I've always been fascinated by Operation Paperclip [0], the US effort to collect Nazi scientists that including Wernher von Braun (of V2 infamy and Saturn V fame). As Tom Lehrer sang [1], " 'Once the rockets are up, who cares where they come down? That's not my department,' says Wernher von Braun. " [0]: [LINK] [1]: [VIDEO] — otras, 2018-12
I didn't intend to imply that he did, apologies. I realize my original post was poorly phrased, so I edited out that part. It's the people saying either that Cisco couldn't have possibly known what China would do with tech designed specifically to track a suppressed religious group, or else doing the Werner von Braun defense[1], that I'm referring to. [1] "'Once the rockets are up, who cares wher… — PhasmaFelis, 2016-04

Related videos