Giving birth costs a lot. Hospitals won't tell you how much.

Channel:Vox · Length:8:16 · Published:2016-05-05 · Views:3370266

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A Vox reporter tries to learn what his son's birth would cost before it happens and fails, showing how opaque US hospital pricing is even for the most common procedure.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it as the go-to example of how impossible it is to get prices in advance for US medical care.

Here's a great video that I think is related to this topic about the near-impossibility of finding out the cost of giving birth — HN, 2017

Microeconomics & behavioral economics · Media, journalism & propaganda · Medicine & infectious disease

Subtitles (excerpt)

That’s my wife. And she’s pregnant.When you have a baby, there are lots of costs to consider. Isabel: Carseat, and a bassinet, a baby carrier, thermometer. Johnny: Wait, wait, but how much is the actual hospital birth going to cost? Healthcare in the US is significantly more expensive than in other countries. Some experts say that this is partly because consumers don’t go around looking for prices comparing them between hospitals. Like they do when they buy a car or anything else for that matter. So I decided it’d try it out. And see if there was any way to discover in advance how much we would be paying for our baby’s birth. What happens next is at once depressing and horrifying, showing how broken and expensive the American health care system is. There's no way I'm the only person who's ever had this question. Childbirth in the US is the number one reason why people go to the hospital. Almost 4 million women are going to give birth this year and most births are relatively uncomplicated. So you would think that with such a common procedure the price would be generally well known. VO: I wanted to know how much child birth usually costs, so I did what any good child of the internet would do I found this really disturbing study from

On Hacker News

Here's a great video that I think is related to this topic about the near-impossibility of finding out the cost of giving birth: [VIDEO] I'd imagine the reasons for the complexity are the same as an injury. Edit: Just a thought... What if enough consumers went line-by-line AFTER the fact and shared what the specific breakdown of every item cost? So then you'd be able to say, okay, at this hospita… — elicash, 2017-06
You can try to comparison shop all you want, but no hospital will give you details in the chargemaster if they aren't legally obligated to. Even if you are in a position to shop around, journalists have documented their futile attempts to do price estimation for routine procedures. Here's one example: [VIDEO] There have been recent laws that requiring publishing some of that information (which ar… — AlotOfReading, 2022-05
Reminds me of the Vox reporter who tried to get a hospital quote for how much it would cost his wife to have a baby: [VIDEO] I’m sure you can guess the outcome. — elliekelly, 2021-01
Hospitals won’t tell you the costs of treatment ahead of time, even for easily predictable items like baby delivery. It’s impossible to shop around. [VIDEO] — empath75, 2019-05
I find it surprising that the US is seen as strongly free market when things like this crop up all over the place. Here's a video of someone failing to get pricing in advance for a medical procedure and an article about how many simple tasks need licences. The fact that a lot of areas only have 1 broadband provider blows my mind. [VIDEO] [LINK] [LINK] — drchewbacca, 2019-04

Related videos