Bottom Up vs Top Down Design in Clojure - Mark Bastian

Channel:ClojureTV · Length:36:42 · Published:2015-11-16 · Views:29163

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Mark Bastian contrasts top-down object-oriented design with bottom-up, data-oriented design in Clojure. He models a board game as plain data plus small composable functions and compares it with a roughly 22-class OOP version.

Why HN recommends it

HN repeatedly recommends it as the talk that made data-oriented, REPL-driven bottom-up design click.

is the talk that really made it clear to me how to design programs this way. — HN, 2021

Functional programming · Software architecture & design

Subtitles (excerpt)

I am Mark Bastion this is my first closure con I'm really glad to be here it's been a great conference um today I'm going to talk about uh bottom up versus top down design en closure and in the time since I submitted the abstract and prepared the slides and got until now that title has kind of morphed a little bit uh to API first versus data first design enclosure and really their uh related topics um just a little bit about me um I'm a mechanical engineer by training but I have been doing software development my entire uh professional life um I programmed in a lot of different languages and a lot of different interesting projects um a long time ago I've done you know languages like Pascal Visual Basic fortrend in terms of languages that I have spent uh significant portions of my career doing software development in I've spent uh you know at least four years doing C++ over a decade in Java uh over six years in schola and then the last couple years I have been had the Good Fortune of being able to do a closure both personally and professionally and uh throughout these different experiences I've I've uh had the opportunities to learn both the you know object-oriented programming as well as functional programming techniques I

On Hacker News

This strikes me as a perfect visual example of repl-driven development. I like how he starts very simple and slowly makes it more sophisticated, testing every step of the way. If you've never tried it before, I highly recommend giving it a shot - it's extremely satisfying. I use Clojure, but other lisps also have fantastic repl environments that facilitate this style of development. "Bottom Up vs… — robto, 2021-04
I picked on needless complexity due to top-down design not on static typing per se. Here's a good video highlighting the difference of approach. Well worth watching. Applies to how many Java architects would design a solution. I see the same kind of top-down approach happening in the Typescript area as well. [VIDEO] — beders, 2019-04
This is exactly my impression after taking a quick glance through these articles as well. If anyone is curious and would like to see a practical demonstration of this data-oriented approach of modelling problems, I highly recommend this talk from Mark Bastian in Clojure/conj 2015: [VIDEO] In it, he contrasts the data-oriented modelling approach with a traditional OOP approach for implementing a b… — lewisl9029, 2018-02
I personally prefer a more data-oriented approach to modeling, as opposed to modeling in terms of objects and relations. One of my favorite videos from Clojure Conj last year talks about the approach in more detail and contrasts it with traditional OO modeling in the context of a board game: [VIDEO] In summary, modeling the board game with data (state) and pure functions (state transitions) had s… — lewisl9029, 2016-03
I see what you are trying to say. You are saying Clojure is not the right tool to do top-down design. I agree with it. It is however a very good tool to do bottom up design. See [VIDEO] — abc_lisper, 2017-01

Related videos