If Brains are Computers, Who Designs the Software? - with Daniel Dennett

Channel:The Royal Institution · Length:1:16:21 · Published:2017-04-06 · Views:873883

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Daniel Dennett's Royal Institution lecture on whether the brain is a computer and where its software comes from. He argues that minds are built by evolution and culture, with competence arising without comprehension.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as an excellent entry point to Dennett's thinking on minds, memes and competence without comprehension.

I discovered him with the excellent Royal Institution talk — HN, 2024

Consciousness & cognition · Evolution & genetics · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

I think probably everything I say tonight I have said in several versions to the students at New College of the Humanities in the last few years when I've given lectures. They've very much helped me write the book that's now emerged. And I was thinking, just as you were introducing me, of a science teacher I had when I was 16 or so, who said a wonderful thing-- a physics teacher. He said science done right is one of the humanities. And I thought, oh, what a great idea. And I sort of kept that in my mind all along. And when Anthony at New College of the Humanities asked me-- and, of course, I'm a philosopher-- to do my thing, I knew that I was encouraged to talk about the science that I was interested in, the scientific ideas, which I think are also important philosophical ideas. And that's what I'm going to talk about tonight. So thank you all for coming. If some of you have seen my Royal Institution talk of about two years ago, you will recognise a few slides. This is a later development of my thinking and pretty much lines up with what's in my new book, called From Bacteria to Bach and Back. Here's a sort of punchline. Should be fairly obvious. We are the first intelligent designers in the tree of life.

On Hacker News

I discovered him with the excellent Royal Institution talk "If Brains are Computers, Who Designs the Software?" [0]. And the quote which marked my mind is "How could a slow, mindless process build a thing that could build a thing that a slow mindless process couldn't build on it's own ?". [0] : [VIDEO] — az09mugen, 2024-04
Thanks for the link, I didn't know about that. It's kind of in the autocatalysis way, but more about "memes" in the sense of the book which introduced the term "The selfish gene" by Richard Dawkins. He says it 2 times, it's what drives his speech : At the beginning : [VIDEO] And at the end : [VIDEO] That's a very nice and profound speech asking good questions. — az09mugen, 2024-11
I find Daniel Dennett's framing of competency vs comprehension a good place to start. He did a nice talk at the RI on it some time ago[1]. A previous one overlaps with similar ground[2]. [1] [VIDEO] [2] [LINK] — rthrfrd, 2024-03
I'd recommend Daniel Dennett's talk If Brains are Computers, Who Designs the Software? as a counterpoint to this article [1]. Dennett's talk is a bit long but I mostly enjoyed it, especially when he points out the computerphobia of many of his colleagues. Of course, it's easier for me to agree with Dennett than for many other people, because I'm a computationalist in the philosophy of mind and su… — 13415, 2020-07
That article reminds me a lot this sentence from Daniel Benett : "How could a slow, mindless process build a thing that could build a thing that a slow mindless process couldn't build on it's own ?" Source : [VIDEO] — az09mugen, 2024-11

Related videos