Pacific Northwest Scala 2013 We're Doing It All Wrong by Paul Phillips

Channel:Confreaks · Length:50:43 · Published:2013-10-25 · Views:64559

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Paul Phillips, a former Scala core contributor, argues after moving a million lines of code that much of what the software industry does is wrong. He critiques Scala and compiler design and calls for better approaches.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as an insider's critique of Scala and of non-incremental compilers, often by people warning others off Scala.

Anyone seriously considering Scala should listen to his talk — HN, 2015

Programming language design · Functional programming · Compilers, interpreters & program analysis

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] hi uh I'll have you know in advance that I'm as disappointed by this talk as you will be the same thing always happens I put 10 times the work into one of these things that I really ought to and it's about tenth of what I would like so now you know expectations on zero all right I guess everybody doesn't know who I am so that's who I am that that is a complete statement there is not much more to be said because that that bonfire there is my life Over The Last 5 Years uh o ODI keeps a nice even flame over 10 and I'm more of a burnout and uh go home which in fact I have in some sense uh which is why I get to give a talk called we're doing it all wrong because in principle I'm not the one doing it all wrong anymore I don't know if that's the case or not we'll see so to understand uh the things that I say you have have to know that it's somewhat emotional for me because I have I mean I have invested a huge chunk of my life certainly like the most productive years of my life in a manner of speaking into uh the skull implementation and typ safe continues on without me and I it's you know they're all my friends over there and you know since scull has got a huge chunk of me in it I'm rooting for these guys completely so please don't infer

On Hacker News

5 years ago, Paul Phillips was still a core contributor to Scala. Anyone seriously considering Scala should listen to his talk, titled “We’re doing it all wrong”, and take a look at Policy, his fork of the Scala compiler. [VIDEO] [LINK] Previous discussion: [LINK] — mietek, 2015-05
If you enjoy these types of compiler videos then I would highly recommend the following rants against Scala by Paul Phillips (from TypeSafe and one of the core language contributors). He also talks about wanting to edit abstract syntax trees directly: [VIDEO] [LINK] — arkadiyt, 2015-05
A bit tangential, but - an ex-Scala core contributor's lament about why compilers have to be incremental: [VIDEO] - a Rust core team member talking about responsive compilers: [LINK] (basically the "low-level" implementation of the talk at the previous link) — pas, 2020-08
Scala's new compiler (dotty) also tries to go that way (first of all using streaming AST-s for better cache locality). The problem is, that usually this "keep state and just percolate changes" is easier said than done. But we're getting there. See also: [VIDEO] (scalac performance) [VIDEO] (what do we really need from "computing science" to do programming) [LINK] — pas, 2016-11
Really good points. I expect you're right about the expressiveness, although I don't really know exactly what you mean by this. The "buffet of abstractions" available in Scala actually put me off it. For me, there are too many options available to expect to have readable, maintainable code at the end of it all, especially if you work in a team which regularly creates almost wilfully hard-to-compr… — bobm_kite9, 2015-08

Related videos